边疆旅游地县域旅游经济时空变迁及驱动机制研究——新疆案例

doi:10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2019.02.19

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 以新疆74个县域单元为研究对象选取多个指标，利用ESDA、ArcGIS和GeoDa等分析方法和手段及动态面板数据模型，分析2008—2017年新疆县域单元旅游经济空间格局演变特征地域差异及驱动机制。结果表明：（1）县域旅游经济集聚特征呈“下降―上升―下降―上升”的态势，彼此之间差异明显，集聚性存在显著的由北向南梯度增强的格局特征。（2）县域旅游经济的“多核心、多条带”分布逐渐形成，但并未改变“北热南冷”的分布格局。（3）受“东北-西南”方向牵引力影响，旅游经济重心轨迹变化呈多个“V”字型重叠分布，也使标准差椭圆的覆盖范围也在此方向上逐渐增大。（4）旅游资源禀赋和政策支持是影响县域旅游经济格局演变的主要驱动因素。交通条件的改善和人力资本水平的提高并非都能促进各县域旅游经济的发展，各影响因素在不同区域间存在明显的强度差异。

关键词: 边疆, 县域, 旅游经济, 时空变迁, 驱动机制

Abstract: As a western frontier region, Xinjiang has gradually become a popular destination for tourism in the northwest of China due to its rich natural and cultural tourism resources generated by its special geographical location and social environment. To grasp the spatial development law of tourism economy is conducive to the formulation of regional tourism economic policies and the sustainable development of regional tourism economy in Xinjiang. The change of spatial pattern of tourism economy is a complicated process. In order to get more accurate and comprehensive analysis of the change process and reasons, taking 74 county units in Xinjiang as the research object and selecting multiple indicators, this paper uses the tools including ESDA, ArcGIS and GeoDa, and the dynamic panel data model to analyze the regional differences and driving mechanism of spatial pattern evolution of tourism economy at the county level in Xinjiang from 2008 to 2017. The results show that the agglomeration of the county scale tourism economy displayed the tendency of " down-up-down-up" because the level of regional tourism development has some correlation with the development of tourism in its neighboring areas. It presents a significant graded change characteristics from the north to the south with an obvious difference from county to county. The enhancement of the fallout of the tourism in the northern regions promoted the interaction between those counties and their neighboring counties and thus formed a spatial distribution pattern of "multi-core and multi-strip", pushing the newly added hot spots southward although this could not change the long-term distribution pattern of "the north being the tourist honeypots while the south being kept in the doghouse” in Xinjiang. Affected by the traction from northeast to southwest, the trajectory of the gravity of the county-scale tourism economy was overlapped with several "V" shapes, which also makes the coverage of the ellipse of the standard deviation be increased gradually in this direction. By regression analysis， there were significant differences in intensity of the influencing factors from county to county. The characteristics of the tourism resources and policy support are the main driving factors. The improvement of traffic condition and human capital level can not necessarily promote the development of county-scale tourism economy in each county. The level of economic development has no obvious influence on the spatial and temporal evolution of tourism economy in the county region.

Key words: , The frontier')">">, county-scale')">">, tourism economic')">">, temporal and spatial change')">">, driving mechanism

朱怡婷, 熊黑钢, 白洋, 杨丽, 曹开军, 唐金稳. 边疆旅游地县域旅游经济时空变迁及驱动机制研究——新疆案例[J]. 干旱区地理, 2019, 42(2): 392-403.

ZHU Yi-ting, XIONG Hei-gang, BAI Yang, YANG Li, CAO Kai-jun, TANG Jin-wen. Spatial and temporal changes and driving mechanism of county-scale tourism in frontier tourism destinations[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2019, 42(2): 392-403.

参考文献 40

[1]	王圣云，单梦静，谭嘉玲．中部地区经济发展跟踪评价与“十三五”加速崛起对策[J]．地域研究与开发，2018，37（1）：20-25．[WANG Shengyun，SHAN Mengjing，TAN Jialing．Comprehensive follow-up evaluation of economic development and strategic countermeasures on rising of Central China in the 13th Five-Year Plan [J].Areal Research and Development，2018，37(1)：20-25．]<br />
[2]	宋慧林，马运来．基于空间分析的中国省域旅游经济差异[J]．经济管理，2010，32（10）：114-118．[SONG Huilin，MA Yunlai．Evaluation on regional disparity of tourism economy in China based on spatial analysis [J]．Business Management Journal，2010，32(10)：114-118．]<br />
[3]	陈刚强．中国地市旅游经济差异的时空演变特征[J]．地域研究与开发，2012，31（4）：91-95．[CHEN Gangqiang．Temporal-spatial evolution of regional tourism economic disparity in China [J]．Areal Research and Development，2012，31(4)：91-95．] <br />
[4]	CHRISTALLER W．Some considerations of tourism location in Europe：The peripheral regions-under-developed countries-recreation areas <br />
[J]	．Papers of the Regional Science Association，1964，(16)：95-105．<br />
[5]	GUNN C A．Vacationscape：Designing tourist regions [M]．NewYork：Van Nostrand Reinhold，1988.<br />
[6]	CHRIS Ryan．Tourism and cultural proximity：Examples from New Zealand [J]．Annals of Tourism Research，2002，29(4)：952-971． <br />
[7]	HILLS T，LUNDGREN J．The impacts of tourism in the Caribean，a method ological study[J]．Annals of Tourism Research，1997，4(5)：248-267． <br />
[8]	BUTLER R W．The concept of a tourist area cycle of evolution：Inplications for management of resources．Canadian Geograoher，1980，(11)：5-12． <br />
[9]	彭宝玉，谢桂珍，魏雪燕，等．中国区域经济、金融发展差异分析[J]．地域研究与开发，2016，35（4）：1-5,11．[PENG Baoyu，XIE Guizhen，WEI Xueyan，et al．Spatial layout pattern of international biopharmaceutical company in China based on value chain specialization[J]．Areal Research and Development，2016，35(4)：1-5,11．]<br />
[10]	彭睿娟．欠发达地区旅游经济差异的空间分析－以甘肃省为例[J]．干旱区地理，2017，40（3）：664-670． [PENG Ruijuan．Spatial analysis of tourism economy disparity of less developed areas in Northwest China[J]．Arid Land Geography，2017，40(3) ：664-670．]<br />
[11]	周礼，蒋金亮．长三角城市旅游竞争力综合评价及其空间分异[J]．经济地理，2015，35（1）：173-179．[ZHOU Li，JIANG Jinliang．Comprehensive evaluation of urban tourism competitiveness in the Yangtze River Delta and its spatial patterns analysis[J]．<br />
	Economic Geography，2015，35(1) ：173-179．]<br />
[12]	苏建军，孙根年．中国旅游投资与旅游经济发展的时空演变与差异分析[J]．干旱区资源与环境，2017，31（1）：185-191．[SU Jianjun，SUN Gennian．Space evolution and difference of tourism investment and tourism economic development in China[J]．Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment，2017，31(1) ：185-191．]<br />
[13]	白洋，瓦哈甫·哈力克，邓峰，等．交通基础设施对区域旅游经济增长的空间效应——基于丝绸之路经济带2001—2014年省际面板数据的分析[J]．陕西师范大学学报(自然科学版)，2017，45（6）：108-114．[BAI Yang，WAHAP Halik，DENG Feng，et al．Spatial effect of traffic infrastructure on regional tourism economic growth：Based on provincial panel data during 2001-2014 in the Silk Road Economic Belt [J]．Journal of Shaanxi Normal University(Natural Science Edition)，2017，45(6)：108-114．]<br />
[14]	孙盼盼，戴学锋．中国区域旅游经济差异的空间统计分析[J]．旅游科学，2014，28（2）：35-48．[SUN Panpan，DAI Xuefeng．An analysis on the spatial data of China's regional tourism economic disparity [J]．Tourism Science，2014，28(2) ：35-48．]<br />
[15]	胡文海，孙建平，余菲菲．安徽省区域旅游经济发展的时空格局演变[J]．地理研究，2015，34（9）：1795-1806．[HU Wenhai，SUN Jianping，YU Feifei．Temporal-spatial evolution patterns of regional tourism economic development in Anhui Province [J]．Geographical Research，2015，34(9) ：1795-1806．]<br />
[16]	唐晓云．生产要素视角的中国旅游经济发展区域差异研究[J]．经济地理，2010，30（10）：1741-1745．[TANG Xiaoyun．Study on regional disparity of tourism development in China：The perspective of factors of production[J]．Economic Geography，2010，30(10) ：1741-1745．]<br />
[17]	钟章奇，李山，王铮，等．中国旅游业空间分异的ABS分析[J]．地理研究，2014，33（8）：1427-1441．[ZHONG Zhangqi，LI Shan，WANG Zheng，et al．Agent-based simulation of the spatial differentiation of the tourism industry in China[J]．Geographical Research，2014，33(8)：1427-1441．]<br />
[18]	张子昂，黄震方，曹芳东，等．浙江省县域入境旅游时空跃迁特征及驱动机制[J]．地理研究，2016，35（6）：1177-1192．[ZHANG Zi＇ang，HUANG Zhenfang，CAO Fangdong，et al．The space-time transition characteristics and its driving mechanism of county-scale inbound tourism in Zhejiang Province[J]．Geographical Research，2014，33(8)：1427-1441．]<br />
[19]	徐冬，黄震方，胡小海，等．浙江省县域旅游效率空间格局演变及其影响因素[J]．经济地理，2018，38（5）：197-207．[XU Dong，HUANG Zhenfang，HU Xiaohai，et al．The spatial pattern evolution and its influencing factors of County-Scale tourism efficiency in Zhejiang Province[J]．Economic Geography，2018，38 (5)：197-207．]<br />
[20]	汪雪，葛幼松．山西省县域经济空间格局及驱动机制分析[J]．地域研究与开发，2018，37（1）：31-35+40．[WANG Xue，GE Yousong．Spatial pattern evolution and driving mechanism analysis of County economy in Shanxi Province[J]．Areal Research and Development，2014，28(2) ：35-48．]<br />
[21]	郭鲁芳．县域旅游经济制度变迁的实证分析-以杭州地区二县市(淳安县、临安市)为例[J]．旅游学刊，2004，（2）：22-25．[GUO Lufang．A demonstrative analysis of institutional changes of County tourism economy:A case of Two Counties (Chun'an and Lin'an) in Hangzhou Area[J]．Tourism Tribune，2004，(2) ：22-25．]<br />
[22]	蒋若凡，李菲雅．汶川县域旅游经济发展模式探索[J]．商业研究，2014，（10）：158-165．[JIANG Ruofan，LI Feiya．Exploration on the development mode of tourism economy in Wenchuan County[J]．Commercial Research，2014，(10) ：158-165．]<br />
[23]	王辉，张萌，石莹，等．中国海岛县的旅游经济集中度与差异化[J]．地理研究，2013，32（4）：776-784．[WANG Hui，ZHANG Meng，SHI Ying，et al．Concentration and differentiation of tourism economy in island counties, China[J]．Geographical Research，2013，32(4)：776-784．]<br />
[24]	陈涛，徐瑶．西部县域旅游发展模式研究-以仪陇县“十二五”旅游发展规划为例[J]．软科学，2013，27（8）：141-144．[CHEN Tao，XU Yao．Research on tourism development planning pattern of Western County Scale:A case of Yilong “Twelve-Five” tourism development planning[J]．Soft Science，2013，27(8) ：141-144．]<br />
[25]	陈建设，朱翔．县域旅游空间布局模型构建研究[J]．经济地理，2012，32（12）：163-168．[CHEN Jianshe，ZHU Xiang．Study on model construction of County tourism spatial layout[J]．Economic Geography，2012，32(12) ：163-168．]<br />
[26]	李瑞，吴殿廷，郭谦，等．20世纪90年代中期以来中国县域旅游研究进展与展望[J]．地理与地理信息科学，2012，28（1）：94-99．[LI Rui，WU Dianting，GUO Qian，et al．Progress and prospect of the research on County tourism in China over the past Fifteen years [J]．Geography and Geo-Information Science，2012，28 (1)：94-99．]<br />
[27]	张建伟，窦攀烽，张永凯，等．江苏省县域创新产出的空间计量经济分析[J]．干旱区地理，2017，40(1) ：222-229．[ ZHANG Jianwei，DOU Panfeng，ZHANG Yongkai，et al．Spatial econometric analysis of innovation output of Jiangsu Province in terms of County scale[J]．Arid Land Geography，2017，40(1) ：222-229．]<br />
[28]	孟德友，陆玉麒．基于县域单元的江苏省农民收入区域格局时空演变[J]．经济地理，2012，32（11）：105-112．[MENG Deyou，LU Yuqi．The spatial-temporal evolution of spatial pattern of rural residents’ net income at County level in Jiangsu[J]．Economic Geography，2012，32(11) ：105-112．]<br />
[29]	陈翊，冯云廷，俞杨安．浙江省县域经济格局的空间演变分析[J]．地域研究与开发，2017，36（3）：16-21．[CHEN Yi，FENG Yunting，YU Yang＇an．Spatial evolution analysis of County-level economy in Zhejiang Province[J]．Areal Research and Development，2017，36(3)：16-21．]<br />
[30]	涂建军，刘莉，张跃，等．1996-2015年我国经济重心的时空演变轨迹-基于291个地级市数据[J]．经济地理，2018，38（2）：18-26．[TU Jianjun，LIU Li，ZHANG Yue，et al．Temporal and spatial evolution of China’s economic center of gravity in 1996-2015:Based on the 291 prefecture-level data[J]．Economic Geography，2018，38 (2)：18-26．]<br />
[31]	李如友，黄常州．江苏省旅游经济重心演进格局及其驱动机制[J]．地域研究与开发，2015，34（1）：93-99,116．[LI Ruyou，HUANG Changzhou．Evolution pattern of the tourism economic gravity center and its driving forces of Jiangsu Province[J]．Areal Research and Development，2015，34(1) ：93-99,116．]<br />
[32]	王慧娟，兰宗敏，金浩，等．基于夜间灯光数据的长江中游城市群城镇体系空间演变研究[J]．经济问题探索，2017,（3）：107-114．[WANG Huijuan，LAN Zongmin，JIN Hao，et al．Spatial evolution of urban system of urban cluster in middle reaches of Yangtze river based on night lighting data [J]．Inquiry Into Economic Issues，2017,(3)：107-114．]<br />
[33]	刘兆德，刘强，刘振明，等．中国省域城-镇化综合水平的空间特征与影响因素[J]．城市发展研究，2017，24（3）：95-101．[LIU Zhaode，LIU Qiang，LIU Zhenming，et al．Spatial characteristics and factors affecting of comprehensive level of urbanization in the Provinces of China [J]．Urban Development Studies，2017，24 (3)：95-101．]<br />
[34]	卢丽文，张毅，李永盛．中国人口城镇化影响因素研究-基于31个省域的空间面板数据[J]．地域研究与开发，2014，33（3）：54-59．[LU Liwen，ZHANG Yi，LI Yongsheng．The factors influence on China population urbanization：Based on 31 Provincial spatial panel data[J]．Areal Research and Development，2014，33 (3) ：54-59．]<br />
[35]	KIM S，TIMOTHY D，HAN H．Tourism and political ideologies：A case of tourism in North Korea[J]．Tourism Management，2006，28(4)：1031-1043． <br />
[36]	KRUGMAN P．The new economic geography，now middle-aged [J]．Regional Studies，2011，45(1)：1-7．<br />
[37]	杨振，雷军，英成龙，等．新疆县域城镇化的综合测度及空间分异格局分析[J]．干旱区地理，2017，40(1)：230-237. [YANG Zhen， LEI Jun，YING Chenglong，et al．Comprehensive measurement and spatial differentiation pattern analysis of the county urbanization in Xinjiang [J]．Arid Land Geography，2017，40 (1)：230-237．]<br />
[38]	杨云．论人力资本积累视野下西部民族地区经济增长方式的转变[J]．经济问题探索，2006,（12）：114-119．[YANG Yun．Transformation of economic growth mode in western minority areas from the perspective of human capital accumulation [J]．Inquiry into Economic Issues，2006,(12)：114-119．] <br />
[39]	孙庆刚，秦放鸣．中国西部少数民族地区经济社会全面发展的影响因素-综述与评价[J]．经济问题探索，2010,（4）：188-190．[SUN Qinggang，QIN Fangming．Factors influencing the overall economic and social development of ethnic minority areas in Western China summary and evaluation [J]．Inquiry into Economic Issues，2010 ,(4)：188-190．] <br />
[40]	顾华详．丝绸之路经济带核心区经济协调发展研究[J]．新疆师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)，2016，37（5）：29-40．[GU Huaxiang．Research in economic coordinated development in Silk-Road Economic Belt in Core Area [J]．Journal of Xinjiang Normal University(Edition of Philosophy and Social Sciences)，2016，37(5)：29-40．]