基于CiteSpace和VOSviewer的区域协调发展的研究进展与展望

doi:10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2024.084

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

基于CiteSpace和VOSviewer软件进行可视化图谱的量化分析，以知网（CNKI）和Web of Science核心数据库为数据源，选取1984—2023年的2221篇中文文献和51篇外文文献，进行关键词共现、关键词时序、关键词聚类密度、关键词突变、作者合作网络、英文文献共被引的可视化分析，从而把握区域协调发展研究整体趋势和热点。结果表明：（1）区域协调发展的研究大体分为萌芽阶段（2004年以前）、快速发展阶段（2004—2017年）、稳步发展阶段（2018年至今）。（2）关键词共现主要在区域协调发展、协调发展、区域经济与协调发展、统筹、一体化、数字经济、科技创新等。关键词突变表明2018年之后新时代、城市群、西部大开发、数字经济等成为区域协调发展研究的前沿。（3）区域协调发展研究的文献作者彼此之间联系并不紧密，缺乏跨地区、跨部门、跨学校、跨研究机构的交流。（4）国外区域协调发展的研究注重区域发展过程中对生态环境的保护。目前，在国家总体规划和政策扶持下，区域协调发展研究随实践深化，旨在解决实际问题，最终回归到实践中。

关键词: 区域协调发展, VOSviewer, CiteSpace, 图谱, 可视化分析

Abstract:

Using CiteSpace and VOSviewer software, a visualization map was quantitatively analyzed. The CNKI and Web of Science core databases served as data sources, providing 2221 Chinese and 51 foreign literature items published from 1984 to 2023. Visual analyses of keyword co-occurrence, keyword timing, keyword cluster density, keyword mutation, author collaboration networks, and English literature co-citation were conducted to identify the overall trends and key areas of focus in regional coordinated development research. The findings are as follows: (1) Research on regional coordinated development can be categorized into three phases: the embryonic stage (pre-2004), the rapid development stage (2004—2017), and the steady development stage (2018—present). (2) Keyword co-occurrence primarily features terms such as regional coordinated development, coordinated development, regional economy, overall planning, integration, digital economy, and scientific and technological innovation. Keyword mutation analysis indicates that since 2018, emerging topics such as the new era, urban agglomeration, western development, and digital economy have become central to regional coordinated development research. (3) Authors contributing to this field show limited interconnectivity, with insufficient communication across regions, departments, academic institutions, and research organizations. (4) Foreign studies on regional coordinated development emphasize ecological environment protection in the context of regional growth. Currently, supported by national plans and policies, research on regional coordinated development is increasingly rooted in practice, aiming to address real-world issues and ultimately return to practical applications.

Key words: regional coordinated development, VOSviewer, CiteSpace, chart, visualization analysis

钟洋, 孔令宇, 董秀军. 基于CiteSpace和VOSviewer的区域协调发展的研究进展与展望[J]. 干旱区地理, 2024, 47(12): 2135-2151.

ZHONG Yang, KONG Lingyu, Dong Xiujun. Research progress and prospects of regional coordinated development based on CiteSpace and VOSviewer[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2024, 47(12): 2135-2151.

图/表 20

图1

图2

图3

图4

图5

图6

图7

图8

图9

图10

图11

图12

图13

图14

图15

图16

图17

图18

图19

图20

参考文献 64

[1]	臧学英, 罗琼. 推动京津冀地区成为全国高质量发展的新动力源[J]. 理论与现代化, 2020(2): 91-99.
	[Zang Xueying, Luo Qiong. Promoting the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region to become the new power source of national high-quality development[J]. Theory and Modernization, 2020(2): 91-99.]
[2]	覃成林, 郑云峰, 张华. 我国区域经济协调发展的趋势及特征分析[J]. 经济地理, 2013, 33(1): 9-14.
	[Qin Chenglin, Zheng Yunfeng, Zhang Hua. A study on the tendencies and features of the coordinated development of regional economy in China[J]. Economic Geography, 2013, 33(1): 9-14.]
[3]	孙铁山, 刘霄泉, 李国平. 中国经济空间格局演化与区域产业变迁——基于1952—2010年省区经济份额变动的实证分析[J]. 地理科学, 2015, 35(1): 56-65. doi: 10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2015.01.56
	[Sun Tieshan, Liu Xiaoquan, Li Guoping. Evolution of China’s spatial economy and regional industrial shift: Empirical analysis of changes in economic shares of Chinese Provinces from 1952 to 2010[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2015, 35(1): 56-65.] doi: 10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2015.01.56
[4]	蒋正云, 刘庆芳, 宋金平. 中国区域经济韧性的格局特征及演化机制[J]. 经济地理, 2023, 43(6): 1-12. doi: 10.15957/j.cnki.jjdl.2023.06.001
	[Jiang Zhengyun, Liu Qingfang, Song Jinping. Pattern characteristics and evolution mechanism of China’s regional economic resilience[J]. Economic Geography, 2023, 43(6): 1-12.] doi: 10.15957/j.cnki.jjdl.2023.06.001
[5]	习近平. 推动形成优势互补高质量发展的区域经济布局[J]. 求是, 2019(24): 4-8.
	[Xi Jinping. Promoting regional economic planning featuring complementary advantages and high-quality development[J]. Qiushi Journal, 2019(24): 4-8.]
[6]	张蕴萍, 栾菁. 数字经济赋能乡村振兴: 理论机制、制约因素与推进路径[J]. 改革, 2022(5): 79-89.
	[Zhang Yunping, Luan Jing. Digital economy enables rural revitalization: Theoretical mechanism, restrictive factors and implementation path[J]. Reform, 2022(5): 79-89.]
[7]	徐政, 左晟吉, 丁守海. 碳达峰、碳中和赋能高质量发展: 内在逻辑与实现路径[J]. 经济学家, 2021(11): 62-71.
	[Xu Zheng, Zuo Chengji, Ding Shouhai. Carbon peak, carbon neutrality empowers high-quality development: Internal logic and realization path[J]. Economist, 2021(11): 62-71.]
[8]	张宇星, 李贵才. 基于CiteSpace的粤港澳研究脉络可视化分析[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(1): 177-189. doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003308
	[Zhang Yuxing, Li Guicai. Visual analysis of Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao research based on CiteSpace[J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(1): 177-189.] doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003308
[9]	Chen C, Morris S. Visualizing evolving networks: Minimum span-ning trees versus pathfinder networks[J]. Information Visualization, 2003: 67-74.
[10]	Chen C M, Song I Y, Yuan X J. The thematic and citation landscape of data and knowledge: Engineering(1985—2007)[J]. Data & Knowledge Engineering, 2008, 67(2): 234-259.
[11]	王业强, 郭叶波, 赵勇, 等. 科技创新驱动区域协调发展: 理论基础与中国实践[J]. 中国软科学, 2017(11): 86-100.
	[Wang Yeqiang, Guo Yebo, Zhao Yong, et al. Coordinated regional development driven by scientific and technological innovation: Theoretical basis and Chinese practice[J]. China Soft Science, 2017(11): 86-100.]
[12]	李崇峰. 辽中南城市群城市功能定位研究[D]. 北京: 中共中央党校, 2016.
	[Li Chongfeng. Research on city function positioning of the middle and southern city cluster of Liaoning[D]. Beijing: Journal of the Party School of the Central Committee of the C.P.C, 2016.]
[13]	何春, 刘来会. 区域协调发展视角下西部大开发政策效应的审视[J]. 经济问题探索, 2016(7): 72-78.
	[He Chun, Liu Laihui. Examination of the policy effects of the western development from the perspective of regional coordinated development[J]. Inquiry into Economic Issues, 2016(7): 72-78.]
[14]	罗黎平. 协调发展视角下区域战略升级及空间干预策略——以湖南省长沙县为例[J]. 经济地理, 2017, 37(11): 46-51.
	[Luo Liping. Regional strategy upgrade and spatial intervention strategy from the perspective of coordinated development: A case study of Changsha County[J]. Economic Geography, 2017, 37(11): 46-51.]
[15]	樊杰, 刘汉初. “十三五”时期科技创新驱动对我国区域发展格局变化的影响与适应[J]. 经济地理, 2016, 36(1): 1-9.
	[Fan Jie, Liu Hanchu. Impacts and adaptation of China’s regional development pattern changes influenced by scientific and technological innovation driven during the Thirteenth National Five-Year Plan Period[J]. Econmic Geography, 2016, 36(1): 1-9.]
[16]	杨玉欢, 贺建雄, 张新红, 等. 中国农文旅耦合协调发展空间分异特征及影响肌理[J]. 干旱区地理, 2023, 46(3): 448-459. doi: 10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2022.295
	[Yang Yuhuan, He Jianxiong, Zhang Xinhong, et al. Spatial differentiation characteristics and influencing texture of the coupling coordinated development of agro-culture-tourism in China[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2023, 46(3): 448-459.] doi: 10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2022.295
[17]	邹德玲, 丛海彬, 李钰, 等. 长三角城市群内小城镇产业集聚效率时空演变与影响因素[J]. 经济地理, 2023, 43(4): 73-82. doi: 10.15957/j.cnki.jjdl.2023.04.008
	[Zou Deling, Cong Haibin, Li Yu, et al. Spatiotemporal evolution and influencing factors of industrial agglomeration efficiency in small towns of the Yangtze River Delta urban agglomeration[J]. Economic Geography, 2023, 43(4): 73-82.] doi: 10.15957/j.cnki.jjdl.2023.04.008
[18]	姚常成, 沈凯玙. 要素流动视角下数字经济与区域经济的包容性增长效应[J]. 经济地理, 2023, 43(4): 10-19. doi: 10.15957/j.cnki.jjdl.2023.04.002
	[Yao Changcheng, Shen Kaiyu. Digital economy and inclusive growth effects of regional economy: From the perspective of factor mobility[J]. Economic Geography, 2023, 43(4): 10-19.] doi: 10.15957/j.cnki.jjdl.2023.04.002
[19]	郭艺, 曹贤忠, 曾刚. 高铁建设对特殊类型地区产业转型升级的影响——来自资源型城市的证据[J]. 地理研究, 2023, 42(5): 1326-1342. doi: 10.11821/dlyj020220699
	[Guo Yi, Cao Xianzhong, Zeng Gang. Impact of high-speed rail construction on industrial transformation and upgrading in special regions: Evidence from resource-based cities[J]. Geographical Research, 2023, 42(5): 1326-1342.]
[20]	蒋和胜, 孙明茜. “双循环”新发展格局与区域协调发展——基于马克思主义政治经济学视角的解读[J]. 中国经济问题, 2022(4): 11-21.
	[Jiang Hesheng, Sun Mingxi. The“Dual Circulaton”development pattern and the regional harmonious development: Interpretation of the perspective of Marxist political economy[J]. China Economic information, 2022(4): 11-21.]
[21]	Mei L, Xu X P, Chen M X. Regional evolution features and coordinated development strategies for northeast China[J]. Chinese Geographical Science, 2006, 16(4): 378-382.
[22]	Yang Q, Ding Y. Assessing regional sustainability using a model of coordinated development index: A case study of Mainland China[J]. Sustainability, 2014, 6(12): 9282-9304.
[23]	Yuan Y Q, Jin M Z, Ren J F, et al. The dynamic coordinated development of a regional environment-tourism-economy system: A case study from western Hunan Province, China[J]. Sustainability, 2014, 6(8): 5231-5251.
[24]	Cheng K, Fu Q, Li T X, et al. Regional food security risk assessment under the coordinated development of water resources[J]. Natural Hazards, 2015, 78(1): 603-619.
[25]	Li Y R, Wang J, Liu Y S, et al. Problem regions and regional problems of socioeconomic development in China: A perspective from the coordinated development of industrialization, informatization, urbanization and agricultural modernization[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2014, 24(6): 1115-1130.
[26]	Cai B Q, Huang X H. Evaluating the coordinated development of regional innovation ecosystem in China[J]. Ekoloji, 2018, 27(106): 1123-1132.
[27]	Ren D. Diversified monetary policies based on the coordinated development of regional economy[J]. Agro Food Industry Hi-Tech, 2017, 28(1): 3415-3418.
[28]	Zhang J L. Research on the correlation between regional economy and educational investment based on coordinated development theory[J]. Educational Sciences-Theory & Practice, 2018, 18(5): 2547-2553.
[29]	Cheng K, Yao J P, Ren Y T. Evaluation of the coordinated development of regional water resource systems based on a dynamic coupling coordination model[J]. Water Supply, 2019, 19(2): 565-573. doi: 10.2166/ws.2018.102
[30]	Lang W, Pan M Z, Wu J M, et al. The patterns and driving forces of uneven regional growth in ASEAN countries: A tale of two Thailands’ path toward regional coordinated development[J]. Growth and Change, 2021, 52(1): 130-149.
[31]	Liu W W, Liu Z W, Wang L, et al. Regional social development gap and regional coordinated development based on mixed-methods research: Evidence from China[J]. Frontiers in Psychology, 2022, 13: 927011, doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.927011.
[32]	Chen Q Y, Chen S J, Fan T. Research on coordinated development of regional ecological environment environment and economy[J]. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, 2021, 30(5): 5529-5536.
[33]	Gao W. Construction of coordinated development mode between ecological environment and regional economy[J]. Journal of Environmental Protection and Ecology, 2022, 23(6): 2559-2567.
[34]	Wang F, Ge X. Inter-provincial responsibility allocation of carbon emission in China to coordinate regional development[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2022, 29(5): 7025-7041.
[35]	Huang S N, Zhu Q, Liu J L, et al. Analysis of coordinated development of regional logistics and environment based on factor analysis method[J]. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, 2022, 31(3A): 3150-3158.
[36]	She J Y, Du P. Rsearch on the coordinated development of Shanghai’s regional development and low-carbon economy based on the coordination degree model of composite systems[J]. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, 2021, 30(11A): 12439-12445.
[37]	刘寒寒, 叶菁, 王雯雯. 基于CiteSpace和VOSviewer的国内半城市化研究可视化分析[J]. 热带地理, 2022, 42(5): 788-798. doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003480
	[Liu Hanhan, Ye Jing, Wang Wenwen. Visualization analysis of peri-urbanization in China based on CiteSpace and VOSviewer[J]. Tropical Geography, 2022, 42(5): 788-798.] doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003480
[38]	朱冬丽. 浅谈科学发展观与生态文明建设[J]. 黑龙江史志, 2015(7): 336-337.
	[Zhu Dongli. On the scientific outlook on development and the construction of ecological civilization[J]. Heilongjiang Chronicles, 2015(7): 336-337.]
[39]	谢地, 王圣媛. 我国主体功能区建设的演进脉络、内在逻辑与实践要求[J]. 学习与探索, 2023(6): 91-98.
	[Xie Di, Wang Shengyuan. The evolution, internal logic, and practical requirements of the construction of main functional zones in China[J]. Study and Exploration, 2023(6): 91-98.]
[40]	周鹏, 潘嗥. 长三角区域经济协调发展模式管窥[J]. 经济与社会发展, 2008(9): 65-69.
	[Zhou Peng, Pan Hao. On the coordinated economic development model of the Yangtze River Delta region[J]. Economic and Social Development, 2008(9): 65-69.]
[41]	陈铭. 国内大循环背景下区域经济的发展路径研究[J]. 全国流通经济, 2023(14): 117-120.
	[Chen Ming. Research on the development path of regional economy under the background of domestic large circulation[J]. China Circulation Economy, 2023(14): 117-120.]
[42]	苏渝, 王茂春. 数字经济、市场分割与共同富裕[J]. 科技与经济, 2023, 36(3): 91-95.
	[Su Yu, Wang Maochun. Digital economy, market segmentation and common prosperity[J]. Science and Technology and Economy, 2023, 36(3): 91-95.]
[43]	李博, 曲艺. 中国沿海地区产业演化路径依赖及突破对区域经济韧性的影响[J]. 地理学报, 2023, 78(4): 824-839. doi: 10.11821/dlxb202304004
	[Li Bo, Qu Yi. Influence of industrial evolution path dependence and path creation on regional economic resilience: Taking the coastal areas of China as an example[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2023, 78(4): 824-839.]
[44]	陈健. 新发展阶段共同富裕目标下区域协调发展研究[J]. 云南民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2022, 39(4): 14-26.
	[Chen Jian. A study of regional coordinated development with the goal of shared prosperity in the new development stage[J]. Journal of Yunnan Nationalities University (Social Sciences Edition), 2022, 39(4): 14-26.]
[45]	单吉堃, 巢佩玲. 基于CiteSpace的我国宜居城市研究现状与趋势分析[J]. 经济问题, 2022(4): 43-48.
	[Shan Jikun, Chao Peiling. Research status and trend of livable cities in China based on Citespace[J]. On Economic Problems, 2022(4): 43-48.]
[46]	曹晨, 黄贤金. 多要素流视角下黄河“几”字弯都市圈空间网络结构及影响因素研究[J]. 干旱区地理, 2023, 46(6): 993-1003. doi: 10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2022.286
	[Cao Chen, Huang Xianjin. Spatial network structure and its influencing factors of Jiziwan Metropolitan Area of the Yellow River from the perspective of multi-dimensional feature flow[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2023, 46(6): 993-1003.] doi: 10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2022.286
[47]	高昕. 后发地区县域经济跨越式发展的障碍与突破[J]. 区域经济评论, 2022(2): 133-140.
	[Gao Xin. Obstacles and breakthroughs in the leapfrog development of county economy in late developing areas[J]. Regional Economic Review, 2022(2): 133-140.]
[48]	韩建雨, 储海涛. 新型城镇化对共同富裕的影响效应及作用机制[J]. 统计与决策, 2023, 39(12): 126-131.
	[Han Jianyu, Chu Haitao. The effect and mechanism of new urbanization on common prosperity[J]. Statitics and Decision, 2023, 39(12): 126-131.]
[49]	张日波. 新发展格局推动经济高质量发展的机理——基于超边际分析的视角[J]. 浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2023, 53(5): 47-61.
	[Zhang Ribo. The mechanism of new development pattern in promoting high-quality economic development: From the perspective of infra-marginal analysis[J]. Journal of Zhejiang University (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition), 2023, 53(5): 47-61.]
[50]	方嘉麟, 蒋坤能, 唐波, 等. 基于VOSviewer和CiteSpace的国内城中村研究现状和进展分析[J]. 特区经济, 2022, 399(4): 71-75.
	[Fang Jialing, Jiang Kunneng, Tang Bo, et al. Analysis of the current situation and progress of domestic urban village research based on VOSviewer and CiteSpace[J]. Special Zone Economy, 2022, 399(4): 71-75.]
[51]	李乃英. 对开发陕西农业旅游的思考[J]. 人文地理, 1999(2): 78-80.
	[Li Naiying. Study on the agricultural tourism development in Shaanxi Province[J]. Human Geography, 1999(2): 78-80.]
[52]	李南, 李晓东, 刘想, 等. 新疆区域经济联系网络时空格局演变[J]. 干旱区地理, 2022, 45(6): 1978-1987. doi: 10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2022.117
	[Li Nan, Li Xiaodong, Liu Xiang, et al. Evolution of spatial and temporal pattern of regional economic connection net-work in Xinjiang[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2022, 45(6): 1978-1987.] doi: 10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2022.117
[53]	韩雪莹, 王涛, 杨文斌, 等. 中国沙障研究进展与热点分析: 基于Vosviewer和Citespace的图谱量化分析[J]. 中国沙漠, 2021, 41(2): 153-163. doi: 10.7522/j.issn.1000-694X.2020.00117
	[Han Xueying, Wang Tao, Yang Wenbin, et al. Research progress and hotspot analysis of sand barrier in China quantitative analysis of atlas based on Vosviewer and Citespace[J]. Journal of Desert Research, 2021, 41(2): 153-163.] doi: 10.7522/j.issn.1000-694X.2020.00117
[54]	姚树洁, 刘嶺. 新发展阶段东北地区高质量发展探究[J]. 学习与探索, 2022(9): 93-101.
	[Yao Shujie, Liu Ling. Reseach on high-quality development of northeast China in the new development era[J]. Study and Exploration, 2022(9): 93-101.]
[55]	李艳菲. 欠发达地区全面推进乡村振兴的路径研究——以皖北地区为例[J]. 福州党校学报, 2023(3): 79-84.
	[Li Yanfei. Research on the path of promoting rural revitalization in an all round way in underdevelopment: Taking northern Anhui as an example[J]. Journal of the Party School of Fuzhou, 2023(3): 79-84.]
[56]	何周倩, 梁育填, 周克杨. 行业异质性与空间黏性:企业迁移成效的差异及其解释——以英德市产业转移园为例[J]. 人文地理, 2022, 37(1): 109-115.
	[He Zhouqian, Liang Yutian, Zhou Keyang. Industry heterogeneity and spatial stickiness: The difference of firm migration performances and explanation: A case of Yingde industrial transfer park[J]. Huamn Geography, 2022, 37(1): 109-115.]
[57]	李苏, 郭远通, 司宝静. 绿色金融助推乡村振兴的实现机制研究——基于空间溢出效应与门槛效应的经验分析[J]. 林业经济, 2023, 45(5): 53-74.
	[Li Su, Guo Yuantong, Si Baojing. Research on the realization mechanism of green finance to promote rural revitalization[J]. Forestry Economics, 2023, 45(5): 53-74.]
[58]	黄鲁成, 郭鑫, 赵志耘, 等. 资源节约型双碳: 概念缘由—评估方法—中国路径[J]. 中国软科学, 2023(6): 129-141.
	[Huang Lucheng, Guo Xin, Zhao Zhiyun, et al. Resource-conserving carbon peaking and carbon neutrality: Conceptual dimension-evaluation methodology-China path[J]. China Soft Science, 2023(6): 129-141.]
[59]	庞敏, 王俭. 绿色金融与低碳经济耦合协调发展研究[J]. 金融发展评论, 2022(11): 17-36.
	[Pang Min, Wang Jian. Research on the coupling and coordinated development of green finance and low-carbon economy[J]. Financial Development Review, 2022(11): 17-36.]
[60]	王轶, 刘蕾. 从“效率”到“公平”: 乡村产业振兴与农民共同富裕[J]. 中国农村观察, 2023(2): 144-164.
	[Wang Yi, Liu Lei. From “efficiency” to “equity”: Rural industrial revitalization and common prosperity of farmers[J]. China Rural Survey, 2023(2): 144-164.]
[61]	句华. 共同富裕视角下基本公共服务均等化的发展趋势与路径[J]. 国家现代化建设研究, 2022, 1(5): 62-72.
	[Ju Hua. New features and trends of the equalization of basic public services from the perspective of common prosperity[J]. Journal of Modernization Studies, 2022, 1(5): 62-72.]
[62]	杨开忠. 以优化新质生产力布局为中心推动新区域协调发展——新发展阶段和十五五时期区域协调发展战略思路[J]. 区域经济评论, 2024(3): 37-45.
	[Yang Kaizhong. New coordinated regional development strategy centered on optimizing the distribution of new quality productive forces[J]. Regional Economic Review, 2024(3): 37-45.]
[63]	华顿. “放开一线, 管住二线”——上海自贸区解析[J]. 上海经济, 2013(8): 18-22, 8.
	[Hua Dun. Release the first line and control the second line: Analysis of Shanghai free trade zone[J]. Economy Shaghai, 2013(8): 18-22, 8.]
[64]	李振伦. 当心实证主义陷阱——与曾永寿同志商讨[J]. 广西社会科学, 1993(6): 84-87, 109.
	[Li Zhenglun. Beware of positivism Trap: Discussion with comrade Zeng Yongshou[J]. Social Sciences in Guangxi, 1993(6): 84-87, 109.]