城市旅游“三生”竞争力空间分异——以西北五省为例

doi:10.12118/j.issn.1000-6060.2019.03.23

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

基于“三生”理念的指导，以西北五省的29个中国优秀旅游城市为研究对象，建立一套城市生产—生活—生态旅游竞争力模型，利用ESDA方法测算旅游“三生”竞争力的空间集聚程度、自然间断点分级聚类展示旅游生产、生活、生态的空间格局，同时结合相关性分析与AHP赋权解剖其影响因素。结果表明，样本城市旅游“三生”竞争力整体趋弱，空间分布离散，局部地区聚集效应低，其中国内旅游消费、公厕个数和降水量是城市旅游“三生”竞争力的主导因素。最终，29个城市依据实证结果可划分为生产型、生活型和生态型旅游城市，在西北五省共同组建4个“三生”旅游圈，为区域旅游发展提供新型合作机制。

关键词: 西北五省, 城市旅游竞争力, 空间分异, “三生”旅游圈

Abstract: Based on the guidance of the concept of “production life ecology”,this paper investigated the spatial variation of the “production lift ecology” competitiveness in urban tourism for 29 cities in the five provinces in northwest China.First,it established a set of urban “production life ecotourism” competitiveness models,followed by the use of the ESDA method to calculate the spatial agglomeration degree and the natural disjunction points for the classification clusters which basically demonstrated the spatial pattern.The correlation analysis and AHP empowerment are used further to dissect the influencing factors.The results show that the overall competitiveness of the “production life ecology” in tourism of the sample cities is weak,the spatial distribution is discrete,and the local area aggregation effect is low.The domestic tourist consumption,the number of public toilets and the precipitation are the leading factors of the “production life ecology” competitiveness in urban tourism.The 29 cities can be divided into 3 categories based on empirical results: the production oriented type,life oriented type,and ecotype.The formation of 4 “production life ecology” tourism circles in the 5 provinces in northwestern China based on the division will provide new cooperation mechanisms for regional tourism development.

Key words: five provinces in northwestern China, urban tourism competitiveness, spatial differentiation, “productionlifeecology” tourism circle

杨发鹏, 张雪唱, 李宗阳. 城市旅游“三生”竞争力空间分异——以西北五省为例[J]. 干旱区地理, 2019, 42(3): 664-672.

YANG Fapeng, ZHANG Xuechang, LI Zongyang.

Spatial differentiation of the “production life ecology” competitiveness in urban tourism:A case study of five provinces in northwest China [J]. Arid Land Geography, 2019, 42(3): 664-672.

参考文献 33

[1]	任桐，刘继生．吉林省旅游竞争力的空间维度及其障碍度分析[J]．经济地理，2011，31(12)：2138-2143．[REN Tong，LIU Jisheng．Analysis on spatial latitude and obstacle of tourism competition in Jilin Province[J]．Economic Geography，2011，31(12)：2138-2143．]
[2]	陈兆坤．我国城市旅游竞争力提升及发展战略选择[J]．经济师，2001，(11)：52-53．[CHEN Zhaokun.China's urban tourism competitiveness and strategic development of choice[J]．China Economist，2001，(11): 52-53．]
[3]	郑坚强，黄伟雄，黄耀丽．珠江三角洲旅游城市一体化研究[J]．资源开发与市场，2002，6)：48-50．[ZHENG Jianqiang， HUANG Weixiong， HUANG Yaoli.Study on the integration of tour city of Pearl River Delta[J]．Resources Development & Market，2002，(6)：48-50]
[4]	吴军．山东半岛城市群旅游地空间优化研究[A]．中国地理学会、中山大学、中国科学院地理科学与资源研究所．中国地理学会2004年学术年会暨海峡两岸地理学术研讨会论文摘要集[C]．中国地理学会、中山大学、中国科学院地理科学与资源研究所，2004：1．[WU Jun．A Study on spatial optimization of tourism in Shandong Peninsula urban agglomeration [A]．Journal of Geographical Sciences and Natural Resources Research，Chinese Academy of Sciences，Sun Yat-sen University，C]．Chinese Geographical Society，Zhongshan University，Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research，Chinese Academy of Sciences，2004：1．]
[5]	李凡，黄耀丽，叶敏思．城市文化竞争力的定量评价方法及实证研究——以珠江三角洲城市群为例[J]．佛山科学技术学院学报(自然科学版)，2008,(2)：57-61．[LI Fan，HUANG Yaoli，YE Minsi．On the quantitative evaluation of urban cultural competitiveness and demonstration study[J]．Journal of Foshan University (Natural Science Edition), 2008,(2)：57-61．]
[6]	胡宪洋，马嘉，寇永哲．大西安旅游圈旅游规模分布演变及空间特征[J]．经济地理，2013，33(6)：188-192．[HU Xianxiang，MA Jia，KOU Yongzhe．Evolution and spatial characteristics of tourism scale distribution in Xi′an tourism destination circle[J]．Economic Geography，2013，33(6)：188-192．]
[7]	南宇．区域合作视角下的西北五省区旅游空间结构研究[D]．兰州兰州大学，2013．[NAN Yu．Research on spatial structure of tourism industry of northwest region under regional cooperation perspective[D]．Lanzhou:Lanzhou University，2013．]
[8]	戴玲丽．杭州都市圈县域旅游竞争力的空间格局分析[J]．国土与自然资源研究，2014,(3)：64-68．[DAI Lingli．Analysis of spatial pattern of tourism competitiveness in counties in Hangzhou metropolitan area[J]．Territory & Natural Resources Study，2014,(3)：64-68．]
[9]	李松柏．环太湖城市旅游竞争力与区域旅游合作研究[J]．经济地理，2014，34(2)：180-186．[LI Songbo.The tourism competitiveness of cities along the Taihu Lake and regional tourism cooperation[J]．Economic Geography，2014，34(2)：180-186．]
[10]	周礼，蒋金亮．长三角城市旅游竞争力综合评价及其空间分异[J]．经济地理，2015，35(1)：173-179．[ZHOU Li，JIANG Jinliang．Comprehensive evaluation of urban tourism competitiveness in the Yangtze River Delta and its spatial patterns analysis[J]．Economic Geography，2015，35(1)：173-179．]
[11]	高楠，马耀峰，张春晖．中国丝绸之路经济带旅游产业与区域经济的时空耦合分异——基于九省区市1993—2012年面板数据[J]．经济管理，2015，37(9)：111-120．[GAO Nan，MA Yaofeng，ZHANG Chunhui．Spatio-temporal differences of coupling between tourism industry and regional economy in China Silk Road Economic Belt : An empirical analysis based on 9 provinces panel date from 1993 to 2012[J]．Business Management Journal，2015，37(9)：111-120．]
[12]	阴启峰，魏骊蓉．新丝绸之路经济带下库尔勒市文化旅游产业的发展研究[J]．中国商论，2016(26)：120-121．[YIN Qifeng，WEI Lirong．Study on the development of cultural tourism industry in Korla city under the New Silk Road Economic Belt[J]．China Journal of Commerce，2016(26)：120-121．]
[13]	袁小玉，汤文霞．新丝绸之路经济带西北五省旅游业发展战略思考[J]．哈尔滨商业大学学报(社会科学版)，2017,(4)：120-128．[YUAN Xiaoyu，TANG Wenxia．Thinking on the development of tourism the Northwest Five Provinces of the New Silk Road[J]．Journal of Harbin University of Commerce(Social Science Edition)，2017,(4)：120-128．]
[14]	南宇，孙建飞，张萍．丝绸之路背景下甘南藏族自治州旅游产业与文化产业融合问题研究[J]．干旱区资源与环境，2017，31(3)：203-208．[NAN Yu，SUN Jianfei，ZHANG Ping．The integration of tourism industry and cultural industry in Gannan Tibetan autonomous prefecture[J]．Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment，2017，31(3)：203-208．]
[15]	孙斐．基于“新丝绸之路”理念的陕西文化旅游产品开发及应用研究[J]．艺海，2016,(5)：140-141．[SUN Fei．Development and application of Shanxi cultural tourism products based on the concept of "New Silk Road"[J]．Yi Hai，2016,(5)：140-141．]
[16]	覃小华，甘永萍．新丝绸之路建设背景下广西与东盟旅游合作发展研究[J]．东南亚纵横，2014,(8)：9-12．[QIN Xiaohua，GAN Yongping．Study on tourism cooperation between Guangxi and ASEAN under the background of New Silk Road[J]．Around Southeast Asia，2014,(8)：9-12．]
[17]	李小明，王新文，张中华．“新丝绸之路”经济带背景下的区域旅游合作发展模式研究[J]．建筑与文化，2016,(11)：88-89．[LI Xiaoming，WANG Xinwen，ZHANG Zhonghua.Research on development model of regional tourism cooperation under the background of "The New Silk Road" Economic Belt[J]．Architecture & Culture，2016,(11)：88-89．]
[18]	屈小爽．“丝绸之路经济带”西北旅游城市旅游效率评价[J]．统计与决策，2017,(10)：70-74．[QU Xiaoshu．Evaluation of tourism efficiency in the Northwest tourism city of the "Silk Road Economic Belt"[J]. Statistics & Decision，2017,(10)：70-74．]
[19]	习近平．决胜全面建成小康社会夺取新时代中国特色社会主义伟大胜利——在中国共产党第十九次全国代表大会上的报告[J]．中国经济周刊，2017(42)：68-96．[XI Jinping．Decides to build a well-off society in an all-round way and seize the great victory of socialism with Chinese characteristics in a new era - report on the 19th National Congress of The Communist Party of China [J]．China Economic Weekly, 2017 (42): 68-96.]
[20]	习近平．关于《中共中央关于全面深化改革若干重大问题的决定》的说明[J]．求是，2013,(22)：19-27．[XI Jinping．Explanation on the "decision of the central Committee of the Communist Party on several major issues concerning the comprehensive deepening of reform"[J]．Truth Seeking，2013,(22)：19-27．]
[21]	党丽娟，徐勇，高雅．土地利用功能分类及空间结构评价方法——以燕沟流域为例[J]．水土保持研究，2014，21(5)：193-197,203．[DANG Lijuan，XU Yong，GAO Ya．Assessment method of functional land use classification and spatial system :A case study of Yancun watershed[J]．Research of Soil and Water Conservation，2014，21(5)：193-197 , 203．]
[22]	马世发，黄宏源，蔡玉梅，等．基于三生功能优化的国土空间综合分区理论框架[J]．中国国土资源经济，2014，27(11)：31-34．[MA Shifa，HUANG Hongyuan，CAI Yumei，et al．The oretical framework with regard to comprehensive sub-areas of China’s land spaces based on the functional optimization of production, life and ecology[J]．Natural Resource Economics of China，2014，27(11)：31-34．]
[23]	张红旗，许尔琪，朱会义．中国“三生用地”分类及其空间格局[J]．资源科学，2015，37(7)：1332-1338．[ZHANG Hongqi，XU Erqi，ZHU Huiyi．An ecological-living-industrial land classification system and its spatial distribution in China[J]．Resources Science，2015,37(7)：1332-1338．]
[24]	李广东，方创琳．城市生态—生产—生活空间功能定量识别与分析[J]．地理学报，2016，71(1)：49-65．[LI Guangdong，FANG Chuanglin．Quantitative function identification and analysis of urban ecological-production-living spaces[J] . Acta Geographica Sinica，2016，71(1)：49-65．]
[25]	扈万泰，王力国，舒沐晖．城乡规划编制中的“三生空间”划定思考[J]．城市规划，2016，40(5)：21-26,53．[HU Wantai，WANG Liguo，SHU Muhui．Reflections on delimiting the three basic spaces in the compilation of urban and rural plans[J] ．City Planning Review，2016，40(5)：21-26 , 53．]
[26]	王娜，张年国，王阳，等．基于三生融合的城市边缘区绿色生态空间规划——以沈阳市西北绿楔为例[J]．城市规划，2016，40(增刊)：116-120．[WANG Na，ZHANG Nianguo，WANG Yang，et al．Green space planning in urban fringe based on industrial-residential-ecological spatial fusion：A case study of shenyang northwest green wedge[J]．City Planning Review，2016，40(Suppl.1)：116-120．]
[27]	李伟松，李江风，姚尧，等．三生空间重构视角下的镇域农村居民点整治分区——以湖北省荆门市沙洋县官垱镇为例[J]．地域研究与开发，2016，35(1)：139-143．[LI Weifeng，LI Jiangfeng，YAO Yao，et al．Consolidation division of rural residential areas besed on reconstruction of production,living and ecology space: A case study of Guandang Town of Shayang county in Jingmen city of Hubei Province [J]．Areal Research and Development，2016，35(1)：139-143．]
[28]	方创琳，鲍超，张传国．干旱地区生态-生产-生活承载力变化情势与演变情景分析[J]．生态学报，2003,(9)：1915-1923．[FANG Chuanglin，BAO Chao，ZHANG Chuanguo．Analysis on the changing condition and the evolutive scene of the ecology-production-living carrying capacity in arid area:A case study in YuliD istrict in the Lower Reaches of Tarim River[J]．Acta Ecologica Sinica，2003,(9)：1915-1923．]
[29]	陶慧，刘家明，虞虎，等．旅游城镇化地区的空间重构模式——以马洋溪生态旅游区为例[J]．地理研究，2017，36(6)：1123-1137．[TAO Hui，LIU Jiaming，YU Hu，et al．The conceptual model of the spatial restructuring in the region of tourism urbanization: A case study of Mayangxi Ecotourism Area[J]. Geographical Research，2017，36(6)：1123-1137．]
[30]	席建超，王首琨，张瑞英．旅游乡村聚落“生产-生活-生态”空间重构与优化——河北野三坡旅游区苟各庄村的案例实证[J]．自然资源学报，2016，31(3)：425-435．[XI Jianchao，WANG Shoukun，WANG Ruiying．Restructuring and optimizing production-living-ecology space in rural settlements:A case study of Gougezhuang Village at Yesanpo tourism attraction in Hebei province[J]．Journal of Natural Resources，2016，31(3)：425-435．]
[31]	李涛，刘家明，刘锐，等．基于“生产—生活—生态”适宜性的休闲农业旅游开发[J]．经济地理，2016，36(12)：169-176．[LI Tao，LIU Jiaming，LIU Rui，et al．The development of leisure agriculture based on suitability about“production-living-ecology”[J]．Economic Geography，2016，36(12)：169-176．]
[32]	杨岳刚，郑国全．基于“三生”理念的乡村休闲旅游资源分类研究——以浙江省苍南县为例[J]．中国城市林业，2014，12(4)：10-13．[YANG Yuegang，ZHENG Guoquan．Research on rural leisure tourism resources classification based on "production-living-eco" concept:A case study of Cangnan County，Zhejiang Province[J]．Journal of Chinese Urban Forestry，2014，12(4)：10-13．]
[33]	李雪鹏．城市旅游竞争力的指标体系构建及评价研究[D]．辽宁：辽宁师范大学，2010．[LI Xuepeng．Study on urban tourism competitiveness' index system construction and evaluation[D]．Liaoning:Liaoning Normal University，2010．]