大气氮沉降数值模拟的演替进程与模型筛选

干旱区地理 ›› 2013, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (3): 383-392.

大气氮沉降数值模拟的演替进程与模型筛选

常运华^1，2，3，刘学军⁴，李凯辉¹，吕金岭^1，2，宋韦^1，2

（1 中国科学院新疆生态与地理研究所中国科学院干旱区生物地理与生物资源重点实验室，新疆乌鲁木齐 830011；2 中国科学院大学，北京 100049； 3 西北师范大学地理与环境科学学院，甘肃兰州 730070；4 中国农业大学资源与环境学院，北京 100193）

收稿日期:2012-07-18 修回日期:2012-09-24 出版日期:2013-05-25
通讯作者: 刘学军. Email：liu310@cau.edu.cn
作者简介:常运华（1986-）男，湖南人，在读硕士研究生，主要从事大气氮硫沉降模拟及其生态环境效应研究. Email：yhchang1986@gmail.com
基金资助:
中国科学院“百人计划”项目（304）；国家自然科学基金项目（41005001）

Numerical modeling atmospheric nitrogen deposition：evolution process and models’ screening

CHANG Yun-hua^1，2，3，LIU Xue-jun⁴，LI Kai-hui¹，LV Jin-ling^1，2，SONG Wei^1，2

（1 Key Laboratory of Biogeography and Bioresourse in Arid Land, Xinjiang Institute of Ecology and Geography, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Urumqi 830011, Xinjiang, China; 2 Graduate School of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China; 3 College of Geographic and Environmental Sciences, Northwest Normal University, Lanzhou 730070, Gansu, China; 4 College of Resources and Environmental Sciences, China Agricultural University, Beijing 100193, China）

Received:2012-07-18 Revised:2012-09-24 Online:2013-05-25

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 中国是维持全球氮平衡的关键。以大气氮沉降为例，畜禽养殖、化肥施用、能源消耗等人为扰动致使活性氮的排放量与沉降量正持续走高，欧美已率先开展氮沉降及其引发的环境与经济后果的评估。中国省级或更大尺度的沉降规模，空间分布和输移途径资料较难获取，大气传输模型（ATMs）提供了经济可行的解决方案。通过概述ATMs的演进阶段和代表模型，并为应对我国缺乏氮沉降模拟专业模型的问题，建立一个总量近百的大气氮沉降相关模型（排放源含NH3、NOx和SO2的ATMs），以总揽世界模型发展全貌。理论上，模型的检验和相互比较以监测值与模拟值的定性分析为基础，中国面临的困境缺乏全国性的统一监测网络在短期内难以解决。事实上，大气氮沉降模型在污染场和浓度场的模拟过程中受到诸如大气环流、边界层高度等条件的制约进而影响模拟效果。NH3的特性对模型提出了更高要求。一方面通过参考相关文献归纳各种制约条件的相对重要性，另一方面结合模型自身架构（格网大小、垂直精度、气象场获取途径以及扩散模式的选取）、模拟过程（源排放、干沉降和扩散）、设计意图，力图以定性或半定量的方法探讨各个模型应对制约条件的能力，比较各自优劣，以期筛选出适用于模拟省域乃至全国大气氮沉降的数值模型。

关键词: 大气氮沉降, 数值模拟, 研究进展, 模型筛选

Abstract: China is pivotal in determining the global nitrogen（N）balance in terms of nitrogen deposition. Multifarious anthropogenic perturbations，e.g. livestock and poultry breeding，N fertilizer application and fossil fuel combustion have been contributing substantial amounts of Nr emission as well as deposition. EU and US leading the field on assessment of N deposition and its environmental or economic consequences. Comparatively，the magnitude，spatial distribution and transportation patterns of the terrestrial nitrogen deposition in China remain uncertain and need to be investigated provincially and nationally. The atmospheric transport models（ATMs）are regarded as an economic and feasible instrument for the ability of characterizing and predicting nitrogen deposition. In response to the absence of a specialized N deposition model in China，we established an N-related deposition models（NDMs）information base，which covered all ATMs worldwide in which NH₃、NOx and SO₂ emission sources involved，aiming to present an comprehensive overview and critical discussion on the state of the science of NDMs. Theoretically，models’ validation and inter-comparison depend on the quantitative analysis of monitoring data against modeling data. However，the scarcity of unified monitoring network in China posed an insurmountable obstacle to implementation. In fact，the atmosphere is a complex and dynamic system that interacts significantly with the land，water body and plant canopy. It is noted that the NDMs to predict atmospheric concentration and deposition fields of nitrogen are subject to numerous constraints and uncertainties，e.g. meteorological field，circulation patterns and boundary layer height，which will influence the modeling performance more or less. Meanwhile，NH₃ raises additional demands on the models. Therefore，here we tentatively indicated the factors for the differences in models’ performance in terms of the model construction（focused on the grid size，vertical resolution，meteorological field access and the fundamental difference between Eulerian and Lagrangian models），modeling processes（of particular concerning emissions，dry deposition and diffusion）and R & D（Research and Development）original intentions（different initial purposes and priorities setting）. The objective of this study was to evaluate the relative merits of NDMs in a qualitative way，screen out several sound modes for Chinese N deposition modeling at a provincial or national scale in the future.

Key words: atmospheric nitrogen deposition, numerical modeling, research progress, models&rsquo, screening

中图分类号:

X511

常运华，刘学军，李凯辉，吕金岭，宋韦. 大气氮沉降数值模拟的演替进程与模型筛选[J]. 干旱区地理, 2013, 36(3): 383-392.

CHANG Yun-hua，LIU Xue-jun，LI Kai-hui，LV Jin-ling，SONG Wei. Numerical modeling atmospheric nitrogen deposition：evolution process and models’ screening[J]. , 2013, 36(3): 383-392.

参考文献

1.GOULDING KWT. Nitrogen deposition to land from the atmosphere［J］. Soil Use Manage，1990，6（2）：61-63.

2.GALLOWAY J N，ERISMAN J W，TOWNSEND A R，et al. UNESCO-SCOPE policy brief： Human alteration of the nitrogen cycle： threats，benefits and opportunities［EB/OL］. http：//www.nine-esf.org/node/168，April 2007.

3.ERISMAN J W，SUTTON M A，GALLOWAY J N，et al. How a century of ammonia synthesis changed the world［J］.Nature Geoscience，2008，1（10）：636-639.

4.BRAUN E. Reactive nitrogen in the environment： too much or too little of a good thing［R］. Paris：UNEP and WHRC，2007：5-43.

5.BRUNEKREEF B，HOLGATE S T. Air pollution and health［J］.The Lancet，2002，360（9341）：1233-1242.

6.GALLOWAY J N，TOWNSEND A R，ERISMAN J W，et al. Transformation of the nitrogen cycle：Recent trends，questions，and potential solutions［J］. Science，2008，320（5878）：889-892.

7.GALLOWAY J N，COWLING E B，SEITZINGER S P，et al. Reactive nitrogen：Too much of a good thing［J］? Ambio，2002，31（2）：60-63.

8.LIU X J，ZHANGY，HAN W X，et al. Enhanced nitrogen deposition over China［J］. Nature，2013，494（7438）：459-462.

9.ZHAO Y，DUAN L，XING J，et al. Soil acidification in China： Is controlling SO2 emissions enough［J］? Environmental Science & Technology，2009，43（21）：8021-8026.

10.RICHTER A，BURROWS J P，NUSZ H，et al. Increase in tropospheric nitrogen dioxide over China observed from space［J］. Nature，2005，437（7055）：129-132.

11.CLARISSE L，CLERBAUX C，DENTENER F，et al. Global ammonia distribution derived from infrared satellite observations［J］. Nature Geoscience，2009，2（7）：479-483.

12.GOULDING K W T. Nitrogen Deposition to Land from the Atmosphere［J］. Soil Use Manage，1990，6（2）：61-63.

13.FENN M E，HAEUBER R，TONNESEN G S，et al. Nitrogen emissions，deposition，and monitoring in the western United States［J］. Bioscience，2003，53（4）391-403.

14.TARRASON L，SCHAUG J. Transboundaryacidification and eutrophication in Europe［R］. Oslo： EMEP CCC & MSC-W，2000：1-74.

15.ERISMAN J W，DRAAIJERS G P J，DRAAIJERS G P J. Studies in environmental research 63：Studies in environmental research atmospheric deposition in relation to acidification and eutrophication［M］. Amsterdam： Elsevier Science BV，1995：1-405.

16.PUL A，HERTEL O，GEELS C，DORE A J，et al. Atmospheric Ammonia：Modelling of the atmospheric transport and deposition of ammonia at a national and regional Scale［M］. Amsterdam：Springer Netherlands，2009：301-358.

17.SEINFELD J H，PANDIS S N. Atmospheric chemistry and physics：From air pollution to climate change （2nd Edition）［M］. New Jersey： John Wiley & Sons，2006：1-1232.

18.JACOBSON M Z. Atmospheric pollution： History，science，and regulation［B］. Cambridge： Cambridge University Press，2002：1-399.

19.ODÉN S. The acidity problem - An outline of concepts［J］. Water，Air，& Soil Pollution，1976，6（2）：137-166.

20.OTTAR B. An assessment of the OECD study on long range transport of air pollutants （LRTAP）［J］. Atmospheric Environment （1967），1978，12（1-3）：445-454.

21.Galloway J N，Cowling E B. Reactive nitrogen and the world： 200 years of change［J］. Ambio，31（2）：64-71.

22.YAN X，AKIMOTO H，OHARA T. Estimation of nitrous oxide，nitric oxide and ammonia emissionsfrom croplands in East，Southeast and South Asia［J］. Global Change Biology，2003，9（7）：1080-1096.

23.APSIMON H M，WARREN R F.Transboundary air pollution in Europe［J］. Energy Policy，1996，24（7）：631-640.

24.GALLOWAY J N，LIKENS G E.Acid precipitation： The importance of nitric acid［J］. Atmospheric Environment （1967），1981，15（6）：1081-1085.

25.KAISER J. The other global pollutant： Nitrogen proves tough to curb［J］. Science，2001，294（5545）：1268-1269.

26.SCHLESINGER W H. On the fate of anthropogenic nitrogen［J］. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America，2009，106（1）：203-208.

27.LIU X J，SONG L，HE C E，et al. Nitrogen deposition as an important nutrient from the environmentand its impact on ecosystems in China［J］. Journal of Arid Land，2010，2（2）：137-143.

28.雷孝恩，张美根，韩志伟，等. 大气污染数值预报基础和模式［M］. 北京：气象出版社，1998：1.

29.朱建林. 大气酸沉降复杂性研究［D］. 长沙：湖南大学，2010. 9-12.

30.PETERS L K，BERKOWITZ C M，CARMICHAEL G R，et al. The current state and future direction of Eulerian models in simulating the tropospheric chemistry and transport of trace species：a review［J］. Atmospheric Environment，1995，29（2）：189-222.

31.CARMICHAEL G R，PETERS L K. An Eulerian transport/transformation/removal model for SO2 and sulfate - I. Model development［J］. Atmospheric Environment （1967），1984，18（5）：937- 951.

32.LAMB R J. A regional-scale （1 000 km） model of photochemical air pollution：Part 1. Theoretical formulation［R］. Research Triangle Park，NC： Meteorology and Assessment Division，Environmental Sciences Research Laboratory，1983：1-206.

33.GIPSON G L. Guideline for use of City-Specific EKMA in preparing ozone SIPs［R］. Research Triangle Park，NC：USEPA，Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards，1981：1-61.

34.JACK D S. A model of regional long-term average sulfur atmospheric pollution，surface removal，and net horizontal flux［J］. Atmospheric Environment （1967），1981，15（5）：689-701.

35.OLENDRZYNSKI K，BERGE E，BARTNICKI J. Eulerian acid deposition model and its applications［J］. European Journal of Operational Research，2000，122（2）：426-439.

36.CHANG J S，BROST R A，ISAKSEN I S A，et al. A 3-Dimensional Eulerianacid deposition model - physical concepts and formulation［J］. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres，1987，92（D12）：14681-14700.

37.ROBERTSON L，LANGNER J，ENGARDT M. An Eulerian limited-area atmospheric transport model［J］. Journal of Applied Meteorology，1999，38（2）：190-210.

38.EMMONS L. K，WALTERS S，HESS P G，et al. Description and evaluation of the Model for Ozone and Related chemical Tracers，version 4 （MOZART-4）［J］. Geoscientific Model Development，2010，3（1）：43-67.

39.AN J L，UEDA H，MATSUDA K，et al. Simulated impacts of SO2 emissions from the Miyake volcano on concentration and deposition of sulfur oxides in September and October of 2000［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2003，37（22）：3039-3046.

40.WANG T J，JIN L S，LI Z K，et al.A modeling study on acid rain and recommended emission control strategies in China［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2000，34（26）：4467-4477.

41.SINGLES R J，SUTTON M A，WESTON K J.A multi-layer model to describe the atmospheric transport and deposition of ammonia in Great Britain［J］. Atmospheric Environment，1998，32（3）：393-399.

42.DRAXLER R R，TAYLOR A D. Horizontal dispersion parameters for long-range transport modeling［J］. Journal of Applied Meteorology，1982，21（3）：367-372.

43.FOELL W，GREEN C，AMANN M，et al. Energy use，emissions，and air pollution reduction strategies in Asia［J］. Water，Air，& Soil Pollution，1995，85（4）：2277-2282.

44.MCRAE G J，GOODIN W R，SEINFELD J H. Development of a second-generation mathematical model for urban air pollution - I. model formulation［J］. Atmospheric Environment（1967），1982，16（4）：679-696.

45.HASS H，JAKOBS H J，MEMMESHEIMER M. Analysis of a regional model （EURAD） near surface gas concentration predictions using observations from networks［J］. Meteorology and Atmospheric Physics，1995，57（1）：173-200.

46.BRÜCHER W，KESSLER C，KERSCHGENS M J，et al. Simulation of traffic-induced air pollution on regional to local scales［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2000，34（27）：4675-4681.

47.KARAMCHANDANI P，VIJAYARAGHAVAN K，YARWOOD G. Sub-grid scale plume modeling［J］. Atmosphere，2011，2（3）：389-406.

48.ODMAN M T，RUSSELL A G. Multiscalemodeling of pollutant transport and chemistry［J］. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres，1991，96（D4）：7363-7370.

49.MORRIS R E，YARWOOD G，EMERY C A，et al. Recent advances in CAMxair quality modeling［C］// Proceedings of the A & WMA 94th Annual Meeting and Exhibition.Orlando，2001：1-16.

50.PENNER J E，ATHERTON C S，DIGNON J，et al. Tropospheric nitrogen： A three-dimensional study of sources，distributions，and deposition［J］. Journal of Geophysical Research，1991，96（D1）：959-990.

51.ULIASZ M. The atmospheric mesoscale dispersion modeling system［J］. Journal of Applied Meteorology，1993，32（1）：139-140.

52.罗淦，王自发. 全球环境大气输送模式（GEATM）的建立及其验证［J］. 大气科学，2006，30（3）：504-518.

53.WANG Z，MAEDA T，HAYASHI M，et al. A nested air quality prediction modeling system for urban and regional scales： Application for high-ozone episode in Taiwan［J］. Water Air &Soil Pollution，2001，130（1-4）：391-396

54.WANG T J，JIANG F，LI S，et al. Trends in air pollution during 1996-2003 and cross-border transport in city clusters over the Yangtze River Delta region of China［J］. Terrestrial Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences，2007，18（5）：995-1009.

55.WANG T J，MIN J Z，XU Y F，et al. Seasonal variations of anthropogenic sulfate aerosol and direct radiative forcing over China［J］. Meteorology and Atmospheric Physics，2001，84（3）：185-198.

56.BYUN DW，CHING J K S. Science algorithms of the EPA Models-3 community multiscale air quality （CMAQ） modeling system （EPA/600/R-99/030）［R］. Washington DC：USEPA，Office of research and development，1999：1-735.

57.朱蓉，徐大海，孟燕君，等. 城市空气污染数值预报系统CAPPS及其应用［J］. 应用气象学报，2001，12（3）：267-278.

58.韩志伟，杜世勇，雷孝恩，等. 城市空气污染数值预报模式系统及其应用［J］. 中国环境科学，2002，22（3）：202-206.

59.房小怡，蒋维楣，吴涧，等. 城市空气质量数值预报模式系统及其应用［J］. 环境科学学报，2004，24（1）：111-115.

60.SUTTON M A，DRAGOSITS U，TANG Y S，et al. Ammonia emissions from non-agricultural sources in the UK［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2000，34（6）：855-869.

61.董文煊，邢佳，王书肖，等. 1994～2006年中国人为源大气氨排放时空分布［J］. 环境科学，2010，31（7）：1457-1463.

62.ASMAN W A H，SUTTON M A，SCHJORRING J K. Ammonia： emission，atmospheric transport and deposition［J］. New Phytologist，1998，139（1）：27-48.

63.SUTTON M A，BURKHARDT J K，GUERIN D，et al. Development of resistance models to describe measurements of bi-directional ammonia surface-atmosphere exchange［J］. Atmospheric Environment，1998，32（3）：473-480.

64.CARMICHAEL G R，CALORI G，HAYAMI H，et al. The MICS- Asia study： model intercomparison of long-range transport and sulfur deposition in East Asia［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2002，36（2）：175-199.

65.CUVELIER C，THUNIS P，VAUTARD R，et al. CityDelta：A model intercomparison study to explore the impact of emission reductions in European cities in 2010［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2007，41（1）：189-207.

66.JONSON J E，BARTNICKI J，OLENDRZYNSKI K，et al. EMEP Eulerian model for atmospheric transport and depositionof nitrogen species over Europe［J］. Environmental Pollution，1998，102（1，Supplement 1）：289-298.

67.SIMPSON D，FAGERLI H，JONSON J，et al.EMEP status report： Transboundary acidification，eutrophication and ground level ozone in Europe［R］. Oslo：Norwegian Meteorological Institute，2003：1-64.

68.DORE A J，VIENO M，TANG Y S，et al. Modelling the atmospheric transport and deposition of sulphur andnitrogen over the United Kingdom and assessment of the influence of SO2 emissions from international shipping［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2007，41（11）：2355-2367.

69.FOURNIER N，PAIS V A，SUTTON M A，et al. Parallelisation and application of a multi-layer atmospheric transport model to quantify dispersion and deposition of ammonia over the British Isles［J］. Environmental Pollution，2002，116（1）：95-107.

70.KRYZA M，BLAS M，DORE AJ，et al. Fine-resolution modeling of concentration and deposition of nitrogen and sulphur compounds for Poland - Application of the FRAME model［J］. Archives of Environmental Protection，2010，36（1）：49-61.

71.ZHANG Y，DORE AJ，LIU X J，et al. Simulation of nitrogen deposition in the North China Plain by the FRAMEmodel［J］. Biogeosciences，2011，8（11）：3319-3329.

72.APSIMON H M，BARKER B M，KAYIN S. Modelling studies of the atmospheric release and transport of ammonia in anticyclonicepisodes［J］. Atmospheric Environment，1994，28（4）：665-678.

73.FOURNIER N，DORE A J，VIENO M，et al. Modelling the deposition of atmospheric oxidised nitrogen and sulphur to the United Kingdom using a multi-layer long-range transport model［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2004，38（5）：683-694.

74.HALLSWORTH S，DORE A J，BEALEY W J，et al. The role of indicator choice in quantifying the threat of atmospheric ammonia to the `Natura 2000' network［J］. Environmental Science & Policy，2010，13（8）：671-687.

75.VAN PUL A，REIS S，DORE T，et al. Atmospheric ammonia：Modelling the national and regional transport and deposition of ammonia［M］.Amsterdam： Springer Netherlands，2009：409-421.

76.HERTEL O，SKJØTH C A，LØFSTRØM P.Modellingnitrogen deposition on a local scale：a review of the currentstate of the art［J］. Environmental Chemistry，2006，3（5）：317-337.

77.WESELY M L. Parameterization of surface resistances to gaseous dry deposition in regional-scale numerical models［J］. Atmospheric Environment，1989，23（6）：1293-1304.

78.SMITH RI，FOWLER D，SUTTON MA，et al. Regional estimation of pollutant gas drydeposition in the UK：model description，sensitivity analyses and outputs［J］. Atmospheric Environment，2000，34（22）：3757-3777.

79.程声通. 环境系统分析教程［M］. 北京：化学工业出版社，2006：26.

80.FANGY，YOH M，KOBA K，et al. Nitrogen deposition and forest nitrogen cycling along an urban-rural transect in southern China［J］. Global Change Biology，2011，17（2）：872-885.

81.刘学军，张福锁. 环境养分及其在生态系统养分资源管理中的作用—以大气氮沉降为例［J］. 干旱区研究，2009，26（3）：306- 311.

82.LI K H，GONG Y M，SONGW，et al. Responses of CH4，CO2 and N2O fluxes to increasing nitrogen deposition in alpine grassland of the Tianshan Mountains［J］. Chemosphere，2012，doi：10.1016/j.chemosphere.2012.02.077.

83.SONG L，LIU X J，ZHANG F S. Impact of nitrogen addition on plant community in a semi-arid temperate steppe in China［J］. Journal of Arid Land，2012，4（1）：3-10.

84.LI K H，GONG Y M，SONG W，et al. No significant nitrous oxide emissions during spring thaw under grazing and nitrogen fertilization in an alpine grassland［J］. Global Change Biology，2012，18（8）： 2546-2554.

85.安瓦尔·买买提明，张小雷，杨德刚. 阿图什市城市化过程的大气环境污染效应［J］. 干旱区地理，2011，34（4）：635-641.

86.李从娟，李彦，马健，等. 干旱区植物根际土壤养分状况的对比研究［J］. 干旱区地理，2011，34（2）：222-228.

87.CHANG Y H. China needs a tighter PM2.5 limit and a change in priorities［J］. Environmental Science & Technology，2012，46（13）：7069-7070.

88.CHANG Y H，LIU X J，DORE A J. Stemming PM2.5 pollution in China： Re-evaluating the role of ammonia，aviation and non-exhaust road traffic emissions［J］. Environmental Science & Technology，2012，46（24）：13035-13036.

[1]	陈强强, 杨凌. 近30 a黄河流域人地系统研究：脉络、热点及展望[J]. 干旱区地理, 2023, 46(10): 1692-1703.
[2]	杨涛, 杨莲梅, 李建刚, 仝泽鹏. 中国天山西部区域云降水物理野外观测科学试验研究若干进展[J]. 干旱区地理, 2023, 46(10): 1602-1611.
[3]	崔珂军, 李生宇, 王海峰, 范敬龙. 台特玛湖干涸湖盆两种典型风蚀坑的三维流场特征及对风蚀的影响[J]. 干旱区地理, 2022, 45(6): 1784-1794.
[4]	王一航, 夏沛, 刘志锋, 卢文路, 何春阳. 中国绿洲城市土地利用/覆盖变化研究进展[J]. 干旱区地理, 2019, 42(2): 341-353.
[5]	王光焰, 王远见, 桂东伟. 塔里木河流域水资源研究进展[J]. 干旱区地理, 2018, 41(6): 1151-1159.
[6]	穆东, 徐德生, 张璐. 1985—2015年矿产资源区域研究进展知识图谱[J]. 干旱区地理, 2018, 41(2): 420-425.
[7]	吴冰, 刘东伟, 刘华民, 王立新, 卓义. 蒙古高原风蚀颗粒物空间过程数值模拟及预报[J]. 干旱区地理, 2018, 41(2): 334-341.
[8]	吴亚平, 潘高峰, 彭尔兴, 王军, 彭萼辉, 耿福志. 锡北地方铁路风沙防治措施研究[J]. 干旱区地理, 2016, 39(6): 1247-1254.
[9]	吴亚平, 潘高峰, 彭尔兴, 王军, 彭萼辉, 耿福志. 锡北地方铁路风沙防治措施研究[J]. 干旱区地理, 2016, 39(6): 1247-1254.
[10]	吴彬，刘慧，王智. 基于辐射井抽水试验的水文地质参数求解[J]. 干旱区地理, 2013, 36(1): 27-32.
[11]	辛渝，陈洪武，江远安，李元鹏，王铁，余行杰. 基于MM5模拟试验的新疆风能资源统计订正初探[J]. 干旱区地理, 2012, 35(01): 32-45.