环境污染与政府规制:一个新的概念框架与理论分析

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 以环境污染与政府规制为研究对象，通过文献演绎法对现有文献进行比较归纳，得出以下结论：（1）在衡量指标上，大多数专家学者均采用CPI指标、BI指标、ICRG指标等指标，比较单一，且主观性比较强，易受各国的认知程度及被调查者主观判断的影响。（2）大多数学者多数仅仅以SO₂、CO₂以及工业三废等单一污染排放物排放量为指标来衡量环境污染，缺乏环境污染指标体系的构建。（3）在研究方法上，大多数专家学者均采用单方程模型对该问题进行分析，仅有少数学者考虑到利用联立方程考察收入、腐败与环境污染的复杂联系，但没有深入研究不同收入水平下腐败与环境关系的动态变化、腐败对不同地区环境污染的定量评估等问题。为此，本文认为基于异质性理论构建符合世界各国腐败对环境污染影响指标评价体系，如何构建合理的整体性的环境污染指标体系等问题成为全球研究的重点。针对我国特殊国情，特别是我国环境污染改善的结果很大程度上不是经济快速发展的造成的，形成了排污企业与政府环境保护执行部门之间的恶性次优博弈均衡。如何打破这个恶性的次优博弈均衡成为未来有关环境污染问题研究的主要方向之一。

关键词: 环境污染, 政府规制, 环境库茨涅茨曲线, 腐败

Abstract: The research objects are the environment pollution and the government regulation. Through the literature deduction,the paper compared the existing literature and draw the following conclusions. First,there is not a unified regional definition on the cognition of regional differences from the c-urrent researches. Most of the researchers use the CPI index,BI index,ICRG index as the measuring indexes. That is single and subjective,which will be influenced by the cognitive degree of countries and respondents' subjective judgments. Second,the majority of researchers only use single pollution emissions indexes such as SO₂,CO₂ and industrial wastes to measure the environmental pollution,which is lack of the construction of environmental pollution indicators system. Third,from the research method aspect,most researches use single equation model to analyze this problem,only a few researchers consider using the simultaneous equation to investigate the complex relationship between income, corruption and environmental pollution. But they do not deeply study the dynamic relationship change between corruption and environment under different income levels,also the relationship between corruption and the quantitative assessment of environmental pollution in different areas. This paper considers two problems will become the focus of global research. One is constructing the index evaluation system about the world's corruption impaction on the environmental pollution based on the heterogeneity theory;the other is how to construct a reasonable and integrated environmental pollution index system. In view of our country's special situation,especially that the improvement of our country environmental pollution is not the result of economic rapid development, it forms the malignant suboptimal equilibrium between the sewage enterprises and the government environmental protection departments. How to break this vicious suboptimal equilibrium has become one of the main research directions on the problem of environmental pollution in the future.

Key words: environmental pollution, government regulation, environmental Kuznets curve, corruption

中图分类号:

X321

吕臣, 彭淑贞, 方巍. 环境污染与政府规制:一个新的概念框架与理论分析[J]. 干旱区地理, 2016, 39(4): 886-894.

LV Chen, PENG Shu-zhen, FANG Wei. Environmental pollution and government regulation: defining and theoretical analyzing from a new perspective[J]. , 2016, 39(4): 886-894.

参考文献

[1] 国家环保总局环境规划院. 2008-2020年中国环境经济形势分析与预测[M]. 北京:中国环境科学出版社,2008:46.[Chinese Academy for Environmental Planning. China's environmental economic situation analysis and prediction[M]. Beijing:China Environmental Science Press,2008:46.]

[2] 全球环境绩效指数出炉,中国名列116位[EB/OL]. http://money.163.com/12/2012-15-07.[World EPI published,China ranked No.116[EB/OL]. http://money.163.com/12/2012-15-07.]

[3] 朱悦. 辽宁省环渤海地区经济增长与水环境污染水平计量模型研究[J]. 中国人口资源与环境,2014,(S1):65-68.[ZHU Rui. Modeling economic growth and water environmental degradation in the Circum-Bohai-Sea zone of Liaoning Province[J]. China Population,Resources And Environment,2014,(S1):65-68.]

[4] KUZNETS S. Economic growth and income inequality[J]. The American Economic Review,1955,45(1):1-28.

[5] GROSSMAN G M,KRUEGER A B. Environment impact of north American free trade agreement[R]. NBERWorking Paper, 1991:3914.

[6] 叶得明,杨婕妤. 石羊河流域农业经济和生态环境协调发展研究[J]. 干旱区地理,2013,(1):76-83.[YE Deming,YANG Jieyu. Coordinated development between agricultural economy and ecological environment in Shiyang River[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2013,(1):76-83.]

[7] 陆虹.中国环境问题与经济发展的关系分析——以大气污染为例[J]. 财经研究,2000,(10):53-59.[LU Hong. An analysis on China's Economy Development and on statespace model of environment-take air pollution as an example[J]. The Study of Finance and Economics,2000,(10):53-59.]

[8] 陆旸,郭路. 环境库兹涅茨倒U型曲线和环境支出的S型曲线:一个新古典增长框架下的理论解释[J]. 世界经济,2008(12):82-92.[LU Yang,GUO Lu. Environmental Kuznets inverted u-shaped curve of S type curve and environmental spending:a framework of neoclassical growth theory[J]. The Journal of Word Economy,2008,(12):82-92.]

[9] 包群,彭水军. 经济增长与环境污染:基于面板数据的联立方程估计[J]. 世界经济,2006,(11):48-58.[BAO Qun,PENG Shuijun. Economic growth and environmental pollution:simultaneous equation estimation based on panel data[J]. The Journal ofWord Economy,2006,(11):48-58.]

[10] STERN DI,COMMON. Is there an environmental Kuznets Curve for Sulfur?[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,2001,41(2):162-178.

[11] MADDISON D. Environmental Kuznets curves:a spatial econometric approach[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,2006,51(2):218-230.

[12] CAVIGLIA-HARRIS J L,CHAMBERS D,KAHN J R. Taking the "U" out of Kuznets[J]. Ecological Economics,2009,68(4):1149-1159.

[13] STERN DI,COMMON,BARBIER EB. Economic growth and environmental degradation:The environmental Kuznets curve and sustainable development[J]. World Development,1996,24(7):1151-1160.

[14] 王宜强,赵媛. 区域煤炭资源流动及其宏观经济效应初探——以内蒙古为例[J]. 干旱区地理,2015,37(1):163-172.[WANG Yiqiang,ZHAO Yuan. Regional coal resources flow and its macroeconomic effects:a case of Inner Mongolia[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2015,37(1):163-172.]

[15] 吴玉鸣,田斌. 省域环境库兹涅茨曲线的扩展及其决定因素——空间计量经济学模型实证[J]. 地理研究,2012,(4):627-640.[WU Yuming,TIAN Bin. The extension of regionmental Kuznets Curve and its determinants:An empirical research based on spatial ecomometrics model[J]. Geographical Research, 2012,(4):627-640.]

[16] 吴海鹰,张盛林. 西部地区经济发展与环境质量关系的实证研究[J]. 宁夏社会科学,2005,(5):29-33.[WU Haiying,ZHANG Shenglin. In the western region the empirical study of relationship between economic development and environmental quality[J]. Social Sciences in Ningxia,2005,(5):29-33.]

[17] 闫海波,陈敬良,孟媛. 中国省级地下经济与环境污染[J]. 中国人口资源与环境,2012,(11):275-279.[YAN Haibo,CHEN Jingliang,MENG Yuan.Underground economy and environmental pollution of Chinese provincial:A spatial econometric model and its application[J]. China Population,Resources and Environment, 2012,(11):275-279.]

[18] 李治国,周德田. 基于VAR模型的经济增长与环境污染关系实证分析[J]. 企业经济,2013,(8):11-16.[LI Zhiguo,ZHOU Dequan. Based on the VAR model an empirical analysis relationship between economic growth and environmental pollution[J]. Enterprise Economy,2013,(8):11-16.]

[19] JOHN A LIST,CRAIG A. Gallet the Environmental Kuznets Curve:does one size fit all[J]. Ecological Economics,1999,31:409-423.

[20] 张晓. 中国环境政策的总体评价[J]. 中国社会科学,1999,(3):88-89.[ZHANG Xiao. Overall evaluation of China's environmental policy[J]. Socia Sciences In China,1999,(3):88-89.]

[21] 马树才,李国柱. 中国经济增长与环境污染关系的Kuznets曲线[J]. 统计研究,2006,(8):37-40.[MA Shucai,LI Guozhu. China's economic growth the Kuznets curve relationship with environmental pollution[J]. Statistical Research,2006,(8):37-40.]

[22] 于峰,齐建国,田晓林. 经济发展对环境质量影响的实证分析:基于1999-2004年间各省市的面板数据[J]. 中国工业经济, 2006,(8):36-44.[YU Feng,QI Jianguo,TIAN Xiaolin. Empirical analysis on impact of economic development on environmental quality-based on the panel data of Chinese provinces & municipal cities from 1999 to 2004[J]. China Industrial Economy, 2006,(8):36-44.]

[23] 李达,王春晓. 我国经济增长与大气污染物排放的关系:基于分省面板数据的经验研究[J]. 财经科学,2007,(2):43-50.[LI Da,WANG Chunxiao. Panel data analysis on the relationship between economic growth and air pollution in China[J]. Finance & Economics,2007,(2):43-50.]

[24] 崔秀萍,吕君,王珊.生态脆弱区资源型城市生态环境影响评价与调控[J]. 干旱区地理,2015,38(1):148-154.[CUI Xiuping, LV Jun,WANG Shan. Resource-based city ecological environment impact assessment and regulation in ecological fragile region[J]. Arid Land Geography,2015,38(1):148-154.]

[25] 唐志强,曹瑾,党婕. 水资源约束下西北干旱区生态环境与城市化的响应关系研究——以张掖市为例[J]. 干旱区地理,2014, 37(3):520-531.[TANG Zhiqiang,CAO Jin,DANG Jie. Interaction between urbanization and eco-environment in arid area of northwest China with constrained water resources:a case of Zhangye City[J]. Arid Land Geography,2014,37(3):520-531.]

[26] 吴玉萍,董锁成,宋健锋. 北京市经济增长与环境污染水平计量模型研究[J]. 地理研究,2002,(2):239-246.[WU Yuping, DONG Suocheng,SONG Jianfeng. Beijing's economic growth and environmental pollution level measurement model research[J]. Geographical Research,2002,(2):239-246.]

[27] 陈华文,刘康兵. 经济增长与环境质量:环境库兹涅茨曲线的经验分析[J]. 复旦学报(社会科学版),2004,(2):87-94.[CHEN Huawen,LIU Kangbing. Economic growth and environmental quality:an empirical analysis of the environmentel Kuznets curve[J]. Fudan Journal(Social Sciences),2004,(2):87-94.]

[28] 张东海,任志远,冯雪铭,等. 中国西部社会、经济与生态的协调发展时空变化[J]. 干旱区地理,2013,36(3):545-552.[ZHANG Donghai,REN Zhiyuan,FENG Xueming,et al. Dynamic change and spatial difference of coordinated development on economysociety and ecology of western area in China[J]. Arid Land Geography, 2013,36(3):545-552.]

[29] 王飞成,郭其友. 经济增长对环境污染的影响及区域性差异——基于省际动态面板数据模型的研究[J]. 山西财经大学学报,2014,(4):14-26.[WANG Feicheng,GUO Qiyou. The influence of economic growth to environmental pollution and regional heterogeneity[J]. Joumal of Shanxi Finance and Economics University,2014,(4):14-26.]

[30] 王怀成,张连马,蒋晓威. 泛长三角产业发展与环境污染的空间关联性研究[J]. 中国人口资源与环境,2014,(S1):55-59.[WANG Haicheng,ZHANG Lianma,JIANG Xiaowei. The correlation research between industry development and environmental pollution in the space of the Yangtze river delta[J]. China Population,Resources And Environment,2014,(S1):55-59.]

[31] 白永亮,党彦龙,杨树旺. 长江中游城市群生态文明建设合作研究——基于鄂湘赣皖四省经济增长与环境污染差异的比较分析[J]. 甘肃社会科学,2014,(1):199-204.[BAI Yongliang, DANG Yanlong,YANG Shuwang. Cooperative research of ecological civilization construction urban agglomeration in the middle reach of Yangtze river-Based on the difference of economic growth and environmental pollution in E,XIANG,GAN,WAN four provinces[J]. Gansu Social Sciences,2014,(1):199-204.]

[32] 苏梽芳,胡日东,林三强. 环境质量与经济增长库兹尼茨关系空间计量分析[J]. 地理研究,2009,(2):303-310.[SU Zhifang, HU Ridong,LIN Sanqiang. Spatial econometric analysis of Kuznets' relationship between environmental quality and economic growth[J]. Geographical Research,2009,(2):303-310.]

[33] 陈青青,龙志和. 中国省级CO₂排放影响因素的空间计量分析[J]. 中国人口资源与环境,2011,21(11):15-20.[CHEN Qingqing, LONG Zhihe. Chinese provincial spatial econometric analysis of influencing factors on CO₂ emissions[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment,2011,21(11):15-20.]

[34] 孙刚,陆铭,张吉鹏. 反腐败、市场建设与经济增长[J]. 经济学季刊,2005,(S1):1-22.[SUN Gang,LU Ming,ZHANG Jipeng. Anticorruption,market construction and economic growth[J]. China Economic Quarterly,2005,(S1):1-22.]

[35] JAIN A K. Corruption:A review[J]. Journal of Economic Surveys, 2001,15(1):71-121.

[36] 周黎安,陶婧.政府规模、市场化与地区腐败问题研究[J]. 经济研究,2009,(1):57-69.[ZHOU Li,TAO Jing. Government size, market development and corruption[J]. Econmic Research Journal, 2009,(1):57-69.]

[37] MAURO P. Corruption and the composition of government expenditure[J]. Journal of Public Economics,1998,69(2):263-279.

[38] FREDRIKSSON P G,SVENSSON J. Political instability,corruption and policy formation:The case of environmental policy[J]. Journal of Public Economics,2003,87(7):1383-1405.

[39] LOPEZ R,MITRA S. Corruption,pollution,and the Kuznets Environment Curve[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,2000,40(2):137-150.

[40] LEITAO A. Corruption and the Environmental Kuznets Curve:empirical evidence for sulfur[J]. Ecological Economics,2010, 69(11):2191-2201.

[41] DESAI U. Ecological policy and politics in developing countries:growth,democracy and environment[M]. Albany:State University of New York Press,1998.

[42] LIPPE M. Corruption and environment at the local level[R]. Transparency InternationalWorking Paper,1999:99/02.

[43] WELSCH H. Corruption,growth and the environment:A Cross-Country analysis[J]. Environment and Development Economics, 2004,9(5):663-693.

[44] MORSE S. Is corruption bad for environmental sustainability? A Cross-National Analysis[J]. Ecology and Society,2006,11(1):22-36.

[45] COLE MA. Corruption,income and the environment:An empirical analysis[J]. Ecological Economics,2007,62(3):637-647.

[46] LEITAO A. Corruption and the Environmental Kuznets Curve:empirical evidence for sulfur[J]. Ecological Economics,2010, 69(11):2191-2201.

[47] PELLEGRINI L,GERLAGH R. Corruption and environmental policies:What are the implications for the enlarged EU[J]. European Environment,2006,16(3):139-154.

[48] HE J,MAKDISSI P,WODON Q. Corruption,inequality,and environmental regulation[R]. Cahier de Recherche Working Paper, 2007:07/03.

[49] IVANOVA B K. Corruption and air pollution in europe[J]. Oxford Economic Papers,2011,63(1):49-70.

[50] SMARZYNSKA B K,WEI S J. Pollution havens and foreign direct investment:Dirty secret or popular myth[R]. World Bank Policy ResearchWorking Paper,2001:2673.

[51] DAMANIA R,FREDRIKSSON P G,LIST J. A trade liberalization, corruption,and environmental policy formation:Theory and Evidence[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 2003,46(3):490-512.

[52] COLE M A,ELLIOTT R,FREDRIKSSON P G. Endogenous pollution havens:Does FDI influence environmental regulations[J]. Scandinavian Journal of Economics,2006,108(1):157-178.

[53] REHMAN F U,ALI A,NASIR M. Corruption,trade openness, and environmental quality:A panel data analysis of selected south asian countries[J]. Pakistan Development Review,2007, 46(4):673-688.