世界遗产威胁因素分析

干旱区地理 ›› 2016, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (1): 224-232.

• 区域发展 • 上一篇

世界遗产威胁因素分析

王昭国^1,2, 杨兆萍¹, 徐晓亮¹, 杜茜诗慧^1,2, 李东³, 时卉¹

1. 中国科学院新疆生态与地理研究所, 新疆乌鲁木齐 830011;
2. 中国科学院大学, 北京 100049;
3. 新疆财经大学旅游学院, 新疆乌鲁木齐 830012

收稿日期:2015-02-02 修回日期:2015-04-25 出版日期:2016-01-25
通讯作者: 杨兆萍,女,研究员,研究方向为旅游地理和世界自然遗产.Email:yangzp@ms.xjb.ac.cn
作者简介:王昭国(1988-),男,山东临沂市人,博士研究生,主要研究方向为旅游地理和遗产价值保护.Email:wzglinyi2007@163.com
基金资助:
国家自然科学基金项目(41301204);中国科学院西部博士资助项目(XBBS201210)

Analysis of threats to World Heritage

WANG Zhao-guo^1,2, YANG Zhao-ping¹, XU Xiao-liang¹, DU Xi-shi-hui^1,2, LI Dong³, SHI Hui¹

1 Xingjiang institute of ecology and geography, Chinese academy of sciences, Urumqi 830011, Xinjiang, China;
2 University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China;
3 Tourism College of Xinjiang Finance University, Urumqi 830012, Xinjiang, China

Received:2015-02-02 Revised:2015-04-25 Online:2016-01-25

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 世界遗产监测是遗产保护的重要手段,世界遗产中心发布的遗产监测报告总结并评估遗产保护状况,分析各遗产地面临的主要威胁.基于遗产监测报告,在统计分析的基础上,提出威胁强度指数IOT,分析不同地区、类型遗产的威胁因素变化,发现:(1)管理和制度因素是各类和各地区遗产最主要的威胁.(2)由人类活动造成的威胁远大于自然灾害对各类型和各地区遗产的破坏.(3)不同类型遗产威胁强度最大的因素不同,自然遗产的受威胁强度最大.(4)各地区中,其他人类因素、自然资源开发、生物资源利用/改变是威胁强度最高的3 种因素,非洲地区受威胁强度最高.(5)威胁最大的因素中,其他人类因素主要是非法活动,管理和制度因素则是缺乏完善合理的管理体系和保护管理规划.为更好应对世界遗产面临的各种威胁,应制定更为完善合理的遗产保护管理体系和标准,同时加强国际间技术、资金等的合作,广泛开展遗产教育,推动社区参与.

关键词: 威胁, 世界遗产, 遗产监测报告, 遗产保护

Abstract: Monitoring is the key method to protect World Heritage,and the reports on the state of the conservation summarize and analysis the threats to World Heritage. The paper utilizes the reports published by World Heritage Centre,puts forward the index of Intensity of threat,analyzes the space-time change of threats and threat intensity, and obtains conclusions as follows:(1)The management and institutional factors is the most factor threatening World Heritage in each region and type;(2)Impacts of threats caused by human activities is higher than natural disasters;(3)Threats intensity on different type of World Heritage is various,intensity of natural World Heritage is the highest;(4)Africa is the worst region of the World Heritage protection,other human activities, physical resource extraction,biological resource use/modification is the threats with highest intensity in each region and type;(5)Other human activities mainly includes illegal activities,and the lacking of round and reasonable management system and management plan is the major sector of threats of management and institutional factors. In order to keep the security of World Heritage,comprehensive measures should be taken to protect World Heritage from threats. Formulating adaptive management system and standards to guide the protection, strengthening the international cooperation,including assistance of conservation technology and finance,promoting the heritage education to foster trained personnel,and developing community participation,such as heritage tourism.With these measures,the security and conservation ofWorld Heritage will be modified and sustainable.

Key words: threats, World Heritage, report of heritage monitoring, heritage protection

中图分类号:

P590.3

王昭国, 杨兆萍, 徐晓亮, 杜茜诗慧, 李东, 时卉. 世界遗产威胁因素分析[J]. 干旱区地理, 2016, 39(1): 224-232.

WANG Zhao-guo, YANG Zhao-ping, XU Xiao-liang, DU Xi-shi-hui, LI Dong, SHI Hui. Analysis of threats to World Heritage[J]. , 2016, 39(1): 224-232.

参考文献

[1] UNESCO. Convention concerning the protection of the world cultural and natural heritage[R]. 1972.

[2] SHACKLEY M. Visitor management:case studies from World Heritage sites[M]. Oxford:Butterworth-Heinemann,1998.

[3] 中华人民共和国联合国教科文组织全国委员会. 世界遗产与我们[M]. 北京:北京师范大学出版社,2004:2-3.[China National Committee of UNESCO. World heritage and we[M]. Beijing: Beijing Normal University Press,2004:2-3.]

[4] LANZA S G. Flood hazard threat on cultural heritage in the town of Genoa(Italy)[J]. Journal of Cultural Heritage,2003,4 (3):159-167.

[5] CHEN Tongbin. The rescue,conservation,and restoration of heritage sites in the ethnic minority areas ravaged by the Wenchuan earthquake[J]. Frontiers of Architectural Research,2012,1(1): 77-85.

[6] 刘瑛. 地震灾后卧龙川金丝猴栖息地恢复指标研究[D]. 北京: 北京林业大学,2009.[LIU Ying. Indicators for Golden Monkey's habitat restoration after earthquake disaster[D]. Beijing: Beijing Forestry University,2009.]

[7] ALCARAZ TARRAGÜEL A,KROL B,VAN WESTERN C. Analysing the possible impact of landslides and avalanches on cultural heritage in Upper Svaneti,Georgia[J]. Journal of Cultural Heritage,2012,13(4):453-461.

[8] WRIGHT I A,WRIGHT S,GRAHAM K,et al. Environmental protection and management:a water pollution case study within the Greater Blue Mountains World Heritage Area,Australia[J]. Land Use Policy,2011,28(1):353-360.

[9] NAVA S,BECHERINI F,BERNARDI A,et al. An integrated approach to assess air pollution threats to cultural heritage in a semi-confined environment:the case study of Michelozzo's courtyard in Florence(Italy)[J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2010,408(6):1403-1413.

[10] OSTI M,COAD L,FISHER J B,et al. Oil and gas development in the World Heritage and wider protected area network in sub-saharan Africa[J]. Biodiversity and Conservation,2011,20 (9):1863-1877.

[11] CLEVENGER A P,WALTHO N. 2005. Performance indices to identify attributes of highway crossing structures facilitating movement of large mammals[J]. Biological Conservation,121 (3):453-464.

[12] DROST A. Developing sustainable tourism for World Heritage sites[J]. Annals of Tourism Research,1996,23(2):479-484.

[13] PENDLEBURY J,SHORT M,WHILE A. Urban World Heritage sites and the problem of authenticity[J]. Cities,2009,26 (6):349-358.

[14] KIM S S,WONG K K F,CHO M. Assessing the economic value of a World Heritage site and willingness-to-pay determinants: a case of Changdeok Palace[J]. Tourism Management,2007,28 (1):317-322.

[15] LI Mimi,WU Bihu,CAI Liping. Tourism development of World Heritage sites in China:a geographic perspective[J]. Tourism Management,2008,29(2):308-319.

[16] SHAFER C L. A Geography of hope:pursuing the voluntary preservation of America's natural heritage[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning,2004,66(3):127-171.

[17] AAS C,LADKIN A,FLETCHER J. Stakeholder collaboration and heritage management[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2005,32(1):28-48.

[18] 时卉,杨兆萍,韩芳,等. 自然遗产地生态脆弱性分析与评价—以托木尔区域为例[J]. 干旱区地理,2013,36(2):318-328. [SHI Hui,YANG Zhaoping,HAN Fang,et al. Assessment and analysis of eco-environment vulnerability in Tomur Region of natural heritage site[J]. Arid Land Geography,2013,36(2): 318-328.]

[19] CLAESSON S. An ecosystem-based framework for governance and management of maritime cultural heritage in the USA[J]. Marine Policy,2009,33(4):698-706.

[20] TECHERA E J. Safeguarding cultural heritage:law and policy in Fiji[J]. Journal of Cultural Heritage,2011,12(3):329-334.

[21] 周年兴,林振山,黄震芳,等. 世界自然遗产地面临的威胁及中国的保护对策[J]. 自然资源学报,2008,23(1):25-32.[ZHOU Nianxing,LIU Zhenshan,HUANG Zhenfang,et al. Threats on the World Heritage natural sites and China's conservation countermeasures[J]. Journal of Natural Resource,2008,23(1):25-32.]

[22] 孙克勤.世界自然遗产云南三江并流保护区存在的问题和保护对策[J]. 资源与产业,2010,12(6):118-124.[SUN Keqin. Issues and approaches of the Three Parallel Rivers Yunnan Protected areas of the world natural heritage[J]. Resource and Industries, 2010,12(6):118-124.]

[23] 任远,熊康宁,肖时珍. 中国世界自然遗产地资源保护与管理研究进展及启示[J]. 安徽农业科学,2011,39(7):4106-4108. [REN Yuan,XIONG KangnIing,XIAO Shizhen. Research progress and reflection of the protection and management of world natural heritage resources in China[J]. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2011,39(7):4106-4108.]

[24] 邵蕊,杨兆萍,韩芳,等. 天山托木尔自然遗产地地理多样性价值评估与保护分区[J]. 干旱区地理,2011,34(3):525-531. [SHAO Rui,YANG Zhaoping,HAN Fang,et al. Assessment of geodiversity values and protection zoning of Tomur natural heritage site[J]. Arid Land Geography,2011,34(3):525-531.]

[25] 刘玉芝. 美国的国家公园治理模式特征及其启示[J]. 环境保护,2011,(5):68-70.[LIU Yuzhi. Characteristic and enlightenment of the management of national park in United States[J]. Environment Protection,2011,(5):68-70.]

[26] 孙克勤. 世界遗产现状与进展[J]. 地理科学研究,2012,1:45. [SUN Keqin. Status and progress of World Heritage[J]. Geographical Science Research,2012,1:45.]

[27] SAUNDERS K M,HARRISON J J,BUTLER E C V,et al. Recent environmental change and trace metal pollution in World Heritage Bathurst Harbour,Southwest Tasmania,Australia[J]. Journal of Paleolimnology,2013,50(4):471-485.

[28] MAKINO M,MATSUDA H,SAKURAI Y. Expanding fisheries co-management to ecosystem-based management:a case in the Shiretoko World Natural Heritage Aarea,Japan[J]. Marine Policy, 2009,33(2):207-214.

[29] 张明泉,李最雄. 敦煌莫高窟保护中的主要环境问题分析[J]. 干旱区资源与环境,1997,11(1):34-38.[ZHANG Mingquan, LI Zuixiong. Analysis of the main environment problems in preservation of Mogao Grottoes Dunhuang[J]. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,1997,11(1):34-38.]

[30] 刘刚,张俊,刁常宇. 敦煌莫高窟石窟三维数字化技术研究[J]. 敦煌研究,2005,(4):104-109.[LIU Gang,ZANG Jun,DIAO Changyu. Research on the 3D digitization of Mogao Grottoes Dunhuang[J]. Dunhuang Research,2005,(4):104-109.]

[31] KUMMU M. Water management in Angkor:human impacts on hydrology and sediment transportation[J]. Journal of Environmental Management,2009,90(3):1413-1421.

[32] NAGENDRA H,TUCKER C,CARLSON L,et al. Monitoring parks through remote sensing:studies in Nepal and Honduras[J]. Environmental Management,2004,34(5):748-760.

[33] FERNÄNDEZ-PRIETO D,HERNÄNDEZ M,ARINO O,et al. Managing World Heritage sites from space:The BEGo project[C]//Proc of the 2004 Earsel Symposium. 2004.

[34] 张晓. 国外国家风景区名胜区(国家公园)管理和经营评述[J]. 中国园林,1999,15(5):56-60.[ZHANG Xiao. Review on management of foreign national scenic spot (national parks)[J]. Chinese Landscape Architecture,1999,15(5):56-60.]

[35] LLOYD D A. Dorset GA group supports multi-national oil industry field excursion to Britain's first natural World Heritage site,26-29 September 2002[J]. Proceedings of the Geologists' Association,2003,114(2):173-174.